Re: Determinism and the Corpus Callosum

2006-04-04 Thread Joan Warmbold
Interesting that the article you quote David is in the Annual Review of Psychology, which has no particular mindset or agenda. It appears that if a person is seeking publication in the "Genetics" journal as well as neurobiological journals, the goal is to find inborn neurological and genetically-b

Re: Determinism and the Corpus Callosum

2006-04-04 Thread David Epstein
On Tue, 4 Apr 2006, Joan Warmbold went: BTW, I'm continually baffled at why, when differences are discovered between adults' brains structure and chemistry, the assumption is almost always that this difference existed from birth? As we all know, literally thousands of studies have revealed the

Re: Determinism and the Corpus Callosum

2006-04-04 Thread Joan Warmbold
Possibly Scamvougeras et.al. work wasn't published because it didn't stand up to rigorous scrutiny for full publication? Just a thought. BTW, I'm continually baffled at why, when differences are discovered between adults' brains structure and chemistry, the assumption is almost always that this

Re: Determinism and the Corpus Callosum

2006-04-04 Thread Stephen Black
On 4 Apr 2006 at 11:25, Stephen Black wrote: > But I've discovered in the meantime that this refers to a presentation she > made > with Scamvougeras as first author at the Miami meeting of the Society for > Neuroscience > in 1994. I can't get the abstract, but it was cited as recently as 1993

Re: Determinism and the Corpus Callosum

2006-04-04 Thread Stephen Black
Michael Sylvester was challenged about his remark of "talk" of an association between the corpus callosum and sexual orientation. He was asked for a reference. He replied: > It either came from LeVay or check out a Brain/Mind video I thought this was interesting, so I looked into it. There is

Re: Determinism and the Corpus Callosum

2006-04-03 Thread Steven Specht
Sorry, I don't accept that attitude from my students; I will certainly not accept it from my colleagues (no matter what degree they have earned. A degree doesn't give you license to be irresponsible); and I don't expect my colleagues to accept that attitude from me. On Apr 3, 2006, at 12:22 PM

Re: Determinism and the Corpus Callosum

2006-04-03 Thread michael sylvester
-- Original Message -- From: Steven Specht <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Reply-To: "Teaching in the Psychological Sciences" Date: Mon, 03 Apr 2006 11:35:48 -0400 >Michael, >When you make such an assertion, you really should be able to (in fact, >in a way, it is yo

Re: Determinism and the Corpus Callosum

2006-04-03 Thread Steven Specht
Michael, When you make such an assertion, you really should be able to (in fact, in a way, it is your responsibility) provide a specific academic reference. It is my recollection (although I could be wrong) that LeVay's work makes no mention of differences at the level of the corpus callosum.

Re: Determinism and the Corpus Callosum

2006-04-03 Thread michael sylvester
-- Original Message -- From: Steven Specht <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Reply-To: "Teaching in the Psychological Sciences" Date: Mon, 03 Apr 2006 07:58:26 -0400 >Michael, >Would you please provide a reference for your assertion that the >thickness of one's corpus

Re: Determinism and the Corpus Callosum

2006-04-03 Thread Steven Specht
Michael, Would you please provide a reference for your assertion that the thickness of one's corpus callosum is associated with homosexuality? Thank you. -S On Mar 30, 2006, at 1:43 PM, michael sylvester wrote: With so much talk about the thickness of the CC explaining Gay behavior and expla

Determinism and the Corpus Callosum

2006-03-30 Thread michael sylvester
With so much talk about the thickness of the CC explaining Gay behavior and explainimg greater use of the two hemispheres,it would appear that the biological circumstances of one's birth seals one fate. Michael Sylvester,PhD Daytona Beach,Florida _