RE: OSGi Binding

2006-11-09 Thread Wengatz, Nicole
>Sure. I could be available. Nicole, what Timezone are you in? I'm PST, Joel, I believe you are CST. I'm CET (Germany). Having the IRC in the evening (e.g. 19:00 CET or later) would be fine for me. I assume it's anyway easier for me to attend from home (due to the companies firewall). Best regard

Re: DAS as a component extension or a component, was: Exposing DAS as an SCA container - Where contribution should go for better collaboration ?

2006-11-09 Thread Jim Marino
On Nov 9, 2006, at 2:59 PM, Rick wrote: I'm not convinced that DAS really requires it but I'll let them be the judge of that. Just from what I remembered I didn't see the need so I questioned it. I just think when possible it best to integrate at the highest level of the stack that suits

Re: DAS as a component extension or a component, was: Exposing DAS as an SCA container - Where contribution should go for better collaboration ?

2006-11-09 Thread Rick
I'm not convinced that DAS really requires it but I'll let them be the judge of that. Just from what I remembered I didn't see the need so I questioned it. I just think when possible it best to integrate at the highest level of the stack that suits your needs. Jim, you lost me and peeked my int

DAS as a component extension or a component, was: Exposing DAS as an SCA container - Where contribution should go for better collaboration ?

2006-11-09 Thread Jim Marino
On Nov 9, 2006, at 11:34 AM, cr22rc wrote: My understanding is you would need to implement classes from tuscany-spi to implement your container. This is surely specific to Tuscany. The work that was started by Luciano was as I understood it a Pojo that was an SCA component. That should b

Re: OSGi Binding

2006-11-09 Thread Jim Marino
On Nov 9, 2006, at 12:56 PM, Wengatz, Nicole wrote: Hi, thanks for providing the information :-) I like Joels idea to use fragment bundles. Seems to be a good way to solve the classloading challenge. Is there any document available describing the composite trees? Unfortunately not yet (I've

Re: DAS as a POJO service (POJService?)

2006-11-09 Thread Jim Marino
On Nov 9, 2006, at 9:59 AM, Kevin Williams wrote: Jim Marino wrote: Yes ideally, but I guess this config info is going to be quite big - so a whole lot of properties might be required. Maybe it would still be ok and its just that I am not yet used to seeing component defintions wit

Re: OSGi Binding

2006-11-09 Thread Jim Marino
On Nov 9, 2006, at 6:44 AM, Hawkins, Joel wrote: I think an IRC might be helpful. Comments below: Sure. I could be available. Nicole, what Timezone are you in? I'm PST, Joel, I believe you are CST. -Original Message- From: Jim Marino [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Thursday, Nove

RE: OSGi Binding

2006-11-09 Thread Hawkins, Joel
@Nicole: Accessing the classloader corresponding to a particular bundle. It's a back-door cheat like the Declarative Services guys use, and its very implementation-specific. Plus it's nice to have a place to isolate implementation-specific stuff. :-) -Original Message- From: Wengatz, Nic

RE: OSGi Binding

2006-11-09 Thread Wengatz, Nicole
Hi, thanks for providing the information :-) I like Joels idea to use fragment bundles. Seems to be a good way to solve the classloading challenge. Is there any document available describing the composite trees? @Joel: What exactly is Equinox-specific in your osgi.equinox bundle? Thanks Nicole

RE: SCA component invoking a callback from a separate thread

2006-11-09 Thread Martin Leclerc
Ignacio, I made a few minor mistakes in my original email. So here is the better version :-) I am currently experimenting with developing "SIP enabled" SCA components. SIP is an asynchronous request/response, session-based protocol, similar to HTTP. Tuscany is deployed within our SIP applicatio

Re: HttpSession vs Session scope

2006-11-09 Thread Ignacio Silva-Lepe
Yeah, I was going to ask about that. But since CONVERSATIONAL occurs only once in the spec and is then replaced by SESSION, it seemed like a typo to me. And speaking of spec clarifications, would this also include @Session and its attribute values? I.e., do they apply to both conversations and htt

RE: SCA component invoking a callback from a separate thread

2006-11-09 Thread Martin Leclerc
Ignacio, Thanks for the quick reply. I am currently experimenting with writing "SIP enabled" SCA components. SIP is an asynchronous request/response, session-based protocol, similar to HTTP. Tuscany is deployed within our SIP application server. Our SIP app server receives each incoming SIP requ

Re: HttpSession vs Session scope

2006-11-09 Thread Jim Marino
On Nov 9, 2006, at 11:16 AM, Ignacio Silva-Lepe wrote: One of the items to be addressed for conversational services is the definition of a SessionScopeContainer, which seems to be distinct from HttpSessionScopeContainer. If that's the case then one question is what identifier to use for each

Re: Adding 2 webapp jars to binary distro

2006-11-09 Thread Jim Marino
I agree that Tuscany webapps will normally receive or make remote invocations, and these will require Tuscany extensions and their dependencies. These extensions and dependencies can be bundled physically within the war file, or the dependencies can be downloaded at runtime from an external maven

Re: DAS as a POJO service (POJService?)

2006-11-09 Thread Luciano Resende
Ok, but how would that work if service and client are remote ? We would need the property defined on the client, as each client might be using a different config file, and how we would tell the remote DAS service to use that ? and if we specify only a file name, how the remote machine would have

Re: Exposing DAS as an SCA container - Where contribution should go for better collaboration ?

2006-11-09 Thread cr22rc
My understanding is you would need to implement classes from tuscany-spi to implement your container. This is surely specific to Tuscany. The work that was started by Luciano was as I understood it a Pojo that was an SCA component. That should be able to work in any other SCA implementation. T

Re: Exposing DAS as an SCA container - Where contribution should go for better collaboration ?

2006-11-09 Thread ant elder
On 11/9/06, Luciano Resende <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Hi Guys Amita have started work to expose DAS as an SCA container, and we are looking what would be the best way to get collaboration on continuing the task. One of the ways we were thinking was to clean-up what is available today and ge

HttpSession vs Session scope

2006-11-09 Thread Ignacio Silva-Lepe
One of the items to be addressed for conversational services is the definition of a SessionScopeContainer, which seems to be distinct from HttpSessionScopeContainer. If that's the case then one question is what identifier to use for each one. Currently, the value o.a.t.spi.model.Scope.SESSION is b

Re: Exposing DAS as an SCA container - Where contribution should go for better collaboration ?

2006-11-09 Thread Luciano Resende
I think the best possible solution would be what we have discussed as "Declarative DAS", where we would extend the programming model to expose services that interact with a persistent layer in a declarative fashion hiding the implementation details from the service developer, you can see some disc

Re: @DataType annotations in BigBank

2006-11-09 Thread Rick
Thanks Scott. I went ahead and removed them. There was something that had me put it in at one time, but apparently it's been fixed. Scott Kurz wrote: Why does the annotation: @DataType(name = "commonj.sdo.DataObject") appear on both the LoginService and ProfileService interfaces in the BIgB

[jira] Resolved: (TUSCANY-763) Property.getDefault() should return the empty list for many-valued Properties

2006-11-09 Thread Frank Budinsky (JIRA)
[ http://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/TUSCANY-763?page=all ] Frank Budinsky resolved TUSCANY-763. Resolution: Invalid I just found this in the SDO spec: • Property.default!=null requires type.dataType=true and many=false which basically says

Re: Exposing DAS as an SCA container - Where contribution should go for better collaboration ?

2006-11-09 Thread Kevin Williams
I absolutely want the best possible solution to integration and this discussion is helping quit a bit. I may misunderstand but, if we develop implementation.das and an associated container, wont this be usable in another SCA implementation? -- Kevin Rick wrote: I quickly skimmed the threads

Re: DAS as a POJO service (POJService?)

2006-11-09 Thread Kevin Williams
Jim Marino wrote: Yes ideally, but I guess this config info is going to be quite big - so a whole lot of properties might be required. Maybe it would still be ok and its just that I am not yet used to seeing component defintions with lots of properties. :) Why are there so many proper

Re: DAS as a POJO service (POJService?)

2006-11-09 Thread Kevin Williams
Hi Luciano, Some comments in line ... Luciano Resende wrote: Thanks Kevin, some comments below... As for the naming :) I was just calling DAS exposed as an SCA service... On 11/8/06, Kevin Williams < [EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: The term DAS-POJO Service is probably confusing. What I meant i

Re: SCA component invoking a callback from a separate thread

2006-11-09 Thread Ignacio Silva-Lepe
Without looking at your whole component assembly or application, it's not clear to me why you would want to create your own thread. I assume your ComponentService.class includes a @Callback annotation to indicate what its callback interface is. This is sufficient to tell Tuscany that your Componen

Re: @DataType annotations in BigBank

2006-11-09 Thread Luciano Resende
Can this be a side-effect of : http://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/TUSCANY-754 - Luciano On 11/9/06, Raymond Feng <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Hi, Scott. Actually, LoginService amd ProfileService is not required to have the @DataType(name = "commonj.sdo.DataObject") because both interfaces onl

SCA component invoking a callback from a separate thread

2006-11-09 Thread Martin Leclerc
Hi, I am trying to write an SCA component that invokes a callback asynchronously (see code at the bottom of this message). In order to simulate an asynchronous notification, a new thread is created and the callback is invoked from within that thread. When I execute the application it throws

Re: Adding 2 webapp jars to binary distro

2006-11-09 Thread Simon Nash
Jim Marino wrote: On Nov 8, 2006, at 8:38 AM, Simon Nash wrote: Raymond Feng wrote: 1) It seems that you're looking for a collection of tuscany runtime/extension jars which provides you the artifacts to build the web application offline using ant or manually. I don't think it's appropr

Re: @DataType annotations in BigBank

2006-11-09 Thread Raymond Feng
Hi, Scott. Actually, LoginService amd ProfileService is not required to have the @DataType(name = "commonj.sdo.DataObject") because both interfaces only deal with simple java types. You should only apply @DataType to interfaces used by SCDL "interface.xxx" elements. Interfaces generated by S

Re: Adding 2 webapp jars to binary distro

2006-11-09 Thread Simon Nash
Jim, See my comments inline. Simon Jim Marino wrote: On Nov 8, 2006, at 8:40 AM, Simon Nash wrote: Jim, See my comments inline. Simon It seems that if you go down this route you will wind up re- inventing Maven. Maven seems simple enough to me. I had not intended to reinvent mave

Re: [VOTE] Geoff Winn for committer

2006-11-09 Thread Jim Marino
+1 On Nov 9, 2006, at 1:22 AM, Pete Robbins wrote: I'd like to nominate Geoff Winn to become a Tuscany committer. Geoff has been involved with the C++ side of Tuscany since May and has submitted many good patches focusing on SDO C++. Geoff is active on the SDO specification for C++ and is doin

@DataType annotations in BigBank

2006-11-09 Thread Scott Kurz
Why does the annotation: @DataType(name = "commonj.sdo.DataObject") appear on both the LoginService and ProfileService interfaces in the BIgBank sample, while it is commented out in the StockQuoteService? These services do not involve actual SDO DataTypes, right? It seems that it should be only

[jira] Commented: (TUSCANY-763) Property.getDefault() should return the empty list for many-valued Properties

2006-11-09 Thread Frank Budinsky (JIRA)
[ http://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/TUSCANY-763?page=comments#action_12448501 ] Frank Budinsky commented on TUSCANY-763: I'm not sure if the spec is clear on this, but my understanding is that Property.getDefault() is N/A if property

[jira] Commented: (TUSCANY-763) Property.getDefault() should return the empty list for many-valued Properties

2006-11-09 Thread Kelvin Goodson (JIRA)
[ http://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/TUSCANY-763?page=comments#action_12448492 ] Kelvin Goodson commented on TUSCANY-763: In answer to the above comment, the spec says (in sect 3.1.4 of the 2.1 spec draft of 20061016) "If a Property

RE: OSGi Binding

2006-11-09 Thread Hawkins, Joel
I think an IRC might be helpful. Comments below: -Original Message- From: Jim Marino [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Thursday, November 09, 2006 1:12 AM To: tuscany-dev@ws.apache.org Subject: Re: OSGi Binding >...services. I would also like to avoid proxying the OSGi services if >poss

Re: [DAS] Towards a disconnected paging capability

2006-11-09 Thread Brent Daniel
The DataObject would need to be an argument to nextPage(), etc. Basically this is doing the same thing you were suggesting, but it gets rid of the Pager API. Brent On 11/8/06, Kevin Williams <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: I am probably missing something. If we stash the page size and number in the

Re: [VOTE] Geoff Winn for committer

2006-11-09 Thread Frank Budinsky
+1 "Pete Robbins" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote on 11/09/2006 04:22:25 AM: > I'd like to nominate Geoff Winn to become a Tuscany committer. > > Geoff has been involved with the C++ side of Tuscany since May and has > submitted many good patches focusing on SDO C++. > > Geoff is active on the SDO sp

Re: [VOTE] Geoff Winn for committer

2006-11-09 Thread Ignacio Silva-Lepe
+1 On 11/9/06, Pete Robbins <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: I'd like to nominate Geoff Winn to become a Tuscany committer. Geoff has been involved with the C++ side of Tuscany since May and has submitted many good patches focusing on SDO C++. Geoff is active on the SDO specification for C++ and is

Re: Exposing DAS as an SCA container - Where contribution should go for better collaboration ?

2006-11-09 Thread Rick
I quickly skimmed the threads on this and I didn't pick up what the advantage was it making this a "container". The only thing I seen was a tighter integration between DAS and SCA. But as I understand it me this is really a tighter integration between DAS and Tuscany implementation of SCA. In

[jira] Updated: (TUSCANY-703) Update to website

2006-11-09 Thread Venkatakrishnan (JIRA)
[ http://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/TUSCANY-703?page=all ] Venkatakrishnan updated TUSCANY-703: Attachment: tuscany_site_Nov_9.zip Hi, The popular GREEN is back :). The modified site files have been attached in the zip tuscany_site_Nov_9.zip.

Re: [VOTE] Geoff Winn for committer

2006-11-09 Thread Venkata Krishnan
+1 - Venkat On 11/9/06, kelvin goodson <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: +1 On 09/11/06, Andrew Borley <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > +1 > > On 11/9/06, ant elder <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > On 11/9/06, Pete Robbins <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > > > > I'd like to nominate Geoff Winn to become

Re: [C++] Where next for Tuscany C++?

2006-11-09 Thread Judah Diament
yep - the gory details are at http://msdn.microsoft.com/vstudio/express/visualc/usingpsdk/default.aspx - VC++ Express was designed for .NET/CLR apps - to do native, you need to hook it up to the platform SDK. On 11/9/06, ant elder <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: This was really helpful Judah. One thi

Re: Tuscany Website Updates

2006-11-09 Thread Rick
I agree with the color, my experience is that it sets a theme using different shades and usually matches the logo. If we switch to this brown we should switch the Tuscany logo there too. As for the top tabs from an aesthetics view I liked them and they add another dimension to the site. It

Re: [C++] Where next for Tuscany C++?

2006-11-09 Thread Andrew Borley
On 11/9/06, Simon Laws <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: On 11/8/06, Andrew Borley <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Hi everyone, > > Now M2 is finally available, we should start thinking about what we'd > like to do next in Tuscany C++. There were quite a few items that were > suggested for M2 that we end

Re: [VOTE] Geoff Winn for committer

2006-11-09 Thread kelvin goodson
+1 On 09/11/06, Andrew Borley <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: +1 On 11/9/06, ant elder <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > On 11/9/06, Pete Robbins <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > > I'd like to nominate Geoff Winn to become a Tuscany committer. > > > > Geoff has been involved with the C++ side of Tuscany

Re: [VOTE] Geoff Winn for committer

2006-11-09 Thread Andrew Borley
+1 On 11/9/06, ant elder <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: On 11/9/06, Pete Robbins <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > I'd like to nominate Geoff Winn to become a Tuscany committer. > > Geoff has been involved with the C++ side of Tuscany since May and has > submitted many good patches focusing on SDO C++.

Re: Refactoring commonality amongst Script containers in Java SCA

2006-11-09 Thread ant elder
Thats an excellent idea. I think there are still parts of this that could be made significantly easier by altering the SPI but I'll be happy to have them in utility jar for now. I'll go do this. ...ant On 11/9/06, Jeremy Boynes <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: How about adding a scripting utility

Re: [C++] Where next for Tuscany C++?

2006-11-09 Thread Simon Laws
On 11/8/06, Andrew Borley <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: Hi everyone, Now M2 is finally available, we should start thinking about what we'd like to do next in Tuscany C++. There were quite a few items that were suggested for M2 that we ended up leaving out for time reasons and it would be good to p

Re: [VOTE] Geoff Winn for committer

2006-11-09 Thread ant elder
On 11/9/06, Pete Robbins <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: I'd like to nominate Geoff Winn to become a Tuscany committer. Geoff has been involved with the C++ side of Tuscany since May and has submitted many good patches focusing on SDO C++. Geoff is active on the SDO specification for C++ and is doi

Re: [C++] Where next for Tuscany C++?

2006-11-09 Thread ant elder
This was really helpful Judah. One thing i found was that before I could get very far with building in Visual Studio at step 8 i had to tell it about a couple of platform SDK directories: In Visual Studio go Tools -> Options, in Projects and Solutions select VC++ Directories, in "Show Directories

Re: ServletLauncherInitException: Autowire target not found

2006-11-09 Thread Jeremy Boynes
There should be absolutely no need for the webapp to have a copy of this scdl unless it is trying to redefine how the system is configured (which is an advanced case). -- Jeremy On Nov 8, 2006, at 2:10 PM, Ignacio Silva-Lepe wrote: To answer my own question, with help from Jim, it turns ou

[VOTE] Geoff Winn for committer

2006-11-09 Thread Pete Robbins
I'd like to nominate Geoff Winn to become a Tuscany committer. Geoff has been involved with the C++ side of Tuscany since May and has submitted many good patches focusing on SDO C++. Geoff is active on the SDO specification for C++ and is doing a great job at the moment raising Jiras documenting

Re: Refactoring commonality amongst Script containers in Java SCA

2006-11-09 Thread Jeremy Boynes
How about adding a scripting utility jar? This would be an additional jar that contained utility classes relevant to scripting extensions that they could all refer too, avoiding duplication but not putting too much implementation in the SPI itself (which I think we all agree should be avoid

Re: Adding 2 webapp jars to binary distro

2006-11-09 Thread Jeremy Boynes
On Nov 8, 2006, at 11:01 PM, Jim Marino wrote: What I would recommend doing to help Ant users is to create a utility that can be invoked from an Ant Task, programmatically, or from the command line which downloads transitive dependencies from a Maven repository. As an implementation strate

Re: Unix patch program

2006-11-09 Thread Jeremy Boynes
--dry-run is also useful On Nov 8, 2006, at 9:59 AM, Davanum Srinivas wrote: -p0 -- dims On 11/8/06, Kevin Williams <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: I have been using Eclipse to apply patches from contributors and I continue to have problems when patches contain additions. I would like to try t

Re: DAS as a POJO service (POJService?)

2006-11-09 Thread Jim Marino
OK. Like Venkat said, I guess you could just have it point to the name of a file as an attribute on implementation.das right? Jim On Nov 8, 2006, at 11:19 PM, Luciano Resende wrote: You could find it here : https://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/incubator/tuscany/java/das/samples/ das.service/src