Re: OT: What the hell is catch-22 [was Re: howto: request committer status]

2004-07-02 Thread Alex Karasulu
That was the title of a famous book by Joseph Heller. http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/0684833395/002-0109254-6032057?v=glance Alex On Thu, 2004-07-01 at 08:50, John Casey wrote: :) sorry. Catch-22 is when no possible action can have a good result...sort of damned if you do,

OT: What the hell is catch-22 [was Re: howto: request committer status]

2004-07-01 Thread Martin Skopp
On Tue, 2004-06-29 at 23:27, John Casey wrote: Catch-22 alleviated. Could please someone explain a non-native speaker like me that mysterious catch-22 term. Thanks folks, -- Martin Skopp Riege Software International GmbH Support: mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED], Information: http://www.riege.com

Re: OT: What the hell is catch-22 [was Re: howto: request committer status]

2004-07-01 Thread John Casey
:) sorry. Catch-22 is when no possible action can have a good result...sort of damned if you do, damned if you don't to use another cliche. HTH, john On Thu, 2004-07-01 at 08:36, Martin Skopp wrote: On Tue, 2004-06-29 at 23:27, John Casey wrote: Catch-22 alleviated. Could please someone

RE: What the hell is catch-22 [was Re: howto: request committer status]

2004-07-01 Thread Peter Bright
: OT: What the hell is catch-22 [was Re: howto: request committer status] On Tue, 2004-06-29 at 23:27, John Casey wrote: Catch-22 alleviated. Could please someone explain a non-native speaker like me that mysterious catch-22 term. Thanks folks, -- Martin Skopp Riege Software

RE: What the hell is catch-22 [was Re: howto: request committer status]

2004-07-01 Thread Göschl,Siegfried
Lovely, it's one of my favorite books ... :-) -Original Message- From: Peter Bright [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Donnerstag, 01. Juli 2004 14:49 To: 'Maven Users List' Subject: RE: What the hell is catch-22 [was Re: howto: request committer status] It's a literary reference

RE: howto: request committer status

2004-06-30 Thread Michael Mattox
Sounds like you just need read only access, you don't need commit for that. Commit is to commit changes to CVS. People usually start out by submitting patches. But if you're just doing a review, read only will work. Everyone has read only, see the project info page of the maven website.

Re: howto: request committer status

2004-06-30 Thread Brill Pappin
Hello Jason, I appreciate the work you and several of your compatriots have done. From my perspective it's moving in the right direction and I've seen you around in several places for several years (I think your the same person anyway). I do know the etiquette for the apache group, though I

RE: howto: request committer status

2004-06-30 Thread Michael Mattox
I think you're the first person who has ever asked for commit status, so the answer is you don't request committer status, it will be offered when someone feels you've earned it. I think you and the others were a little hard on him. I got the impression that he doesn't know how it works and

Re: howto: request committer status

2004-06-29 Thread Jason van Zyl
On Tue, 2004-06-29 at 16:43, Brill Pappin wrote: How do I go about requesting commit status for this project? It is bad etiquette to request committer status in OSS projects and generally looked dimly upon. The normal course of action is you contribute for a period of time and one of the

Re: howto: request committer status

2004-06-29 Thread Craig S . Cottingham
On Jun 29, 2004, at 17:10, Jason van Zyl wrote: On Tue, 2004-06-29 at 16:43, Brill Pappin wrote: How do I go about requesting commit status for this project? It is bad etiquette to request committer status in OSS projects and generally looked dimly upon. The normal course of action is you

Re: howto: request committer status

2004-06-29 Thread Jason van Zyl
On Tue, 2004-06-29 at 18:16, Craig S. Cottingham wrote: On Jun 29, 2004, at 17:10, Jason van Zyl wrote: On Tue, 2004-06-29 at 16:43, Brill Pappin wrote: How do I go about requesting commit status for this project? It is bad etiquette to request committer status in OSS projects and

Re: howto: request committer status

2004-06-29 Thread Brett Porter
No idea what patch, but it was probably me that rejected it. Sorry if it caused an offence, but I always try to give a reason that something is not suitable. If I didn't, or you don't think it's correct, you're welcome to continue to debate it in the relevant JIRA issue, or take it up on the -dev

Re: howto: request committer status

2004-06-29 Thread John Casey
Without getting into the merits of his patch, it's a little bit ridiculous to expect to gain committer status immediately and with no effort on the project. If he can't get the patch through, then he still has the option to fork the war plugin. Catch-22 alleviated. -john On Tue, 2004-06-29 at

Re: howto: request committer status

2004-06-29 Thread John Casey
Brett, AFAIK this is still purely hypothetical. Not to worry. -j On Tue, 2004-06-29 at 19:14, Brett Porter wrote: No idea what patch, but it was probably me that rejected it. Sorry if it caused an offence, but I always try to give a reason that something is not suitable. If I didn't, or you