Re: Standardcompliance of rendered markup

2007-04-06 Thread Rudi Steiner
Hi Jeff, the problem with the t:panelNavigation2/-tag can be reproduced as follows: I defined a tiles template containing a t:panelNavigation2/ f:view h:form t:div id=menu forceId=true t:div id=lftBar forceId=true f:loadBundle

Re: Standardcompliance of rendered markup

2007-04-05 Thread Rudi Steiner
Hi Jeff, testing again the current version bevor taliking about bugs is a great idea ;) The problem for beginners like me is, that on the myFaces website is described, that the fastest way to get a project up and running is to take one of the example-apps (in my case the tiles-app) and take

Re: Standardcompliance of rendered markup

2007-04-05 Thread Jeff Bischoff
Hi Rudi, comments inline. [2] http://people.apache.org/builds/myfaces/nightly/ [3] https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/MYFACES-1414 Rudi Steiner wrote: Hi Jeff, testing again the current version bevor taliking about bugs is a great idea ;) The problem for beginners like me is, that on

Re: Standardcompliance of rendered markup

2007-04-04 Thread Rudi Steiner
Hello, thanks a lot to everybody. @Mike: I removed on form on the page and wrap all the formcontent by one form-element. So this problem is resolved. But valuating the new page, I get the following error for the markup rendered by the t:datatable/ - tag : Error Line 85 column 83: character [

Re: Standardcompliance of rendered markup

2007-04-04 Thread Volker Weber
Hi Rudi, can you post the relevant jsf code, this looks not like a jsf generated id. Regards, Volker 2007/4/4, Rudi Steiner [EMAIL PROTECTED]: Hello, thanks a lot to everybody. @Mike: I removed on form on the page and wrap all the formcontent by one form-element. So this problem is

Re: Standardcompliance of rendered markup

2007-04-04 Thread Rudi Steiner
Hi Volker, the jsf code is the following: t:dataTable forceId=true id=dataTable width=100% styleClass=standardTable headerClass=standardTable_Header

Re: Standardcompliance of rendered markup

2007-04-04 Thread Mike Kienenberger
You need to post the page code generating this particular output: ...dardTable_Columnspan id=ot_servId[0]41315/span/tdtd class=standar It's not being generated by t:dataTable directly. On 4/4/07, Rudi Steiner [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hello, thanks a lot to everybody. @Mike: I removed on

Re: Standardcompliance of rendered markup

2007-04-04 Thread Rudi Steiner
Hi Mike, sorry for my fast reply. The problem isn't resolved. Also when I use just one form-element in my page there is still a second form generated by the framework with the following id form id=linkDummyForm name=linkDummyForm ... This form contains the hidden field input type=hidden

Re: Standardcompliance of rendered markup

2007-04-04 Thread Mike Kienenberger
I don't think that linkDummyForm exists in newer releases. You can try upgrading to MyFaces 1.1.5 and Tomahawk 1.1.5. From what I remember, the linkDummyForm is created when you try to use JSF elements outside of your h:form tag. I don't remember if it was created conditionally or

Re: Standardcompliance of rendered markup

2007-04-04 Thread Jeff Bischoff
Ridu, what version of MyFaces and Tomahawk are you using? DummyForms were once used to allow commandLinks and other components to function despite not being within a form. Recent versions have eliminated the DummyForm because it was incompatible with the RI way of doing things [1]. All such

Re: Standardcompliance of rendered markup

2007-04-04 Thread Jeff Bischoff
I'm sorry I meant to say Rudi. ;) Jeff Bischoff wrote: Ridu, what version of MyFaces and Tomahawk are you using?

Standardcompliance of rendered markup

2007-04-03 Thread Rudi Steiner
Hi all, since my chef ask me about XHTML or HTML 4.0 compliance of the generated HTML-output of MyFaces, today I made some investigations. I figured out that the generated markup is not far from XHTML but some components render invalid markup. Some examples: t:panelNavigation2 / renders the

Re: Standardcompliance of rendered markup

2007-04-03 Thread David Delbecq
Hi Rudi, as far as i know, myfaces is supposed to render xhtml compliant output. The 2 things you mentions are most probably bugs and should be fixed. You should report the to the myfaces issue tracker :) At least, your panelnavigation one is already reported:

Re: Standardcompliance of rendered markup

2007-04-03 Thread Mike Kienenberger
Definitely open JIRA issues (preferrably with patches) for all but one of these items. Error Line 101 column 165: ID jsf_tree_64 already defined. The above will not be fixed -- this element must exist and be submitted in every form. However, it's bad practice to use multiple forms on a

Re: Standardcompliance of rendered markup

2007-04-03 Thread Jörn Zaefferer
On 4/3/07, Mike Kienenberger [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Definitely open JIRA issues (preferrably with patches) for all but one of these items. Error Line 101 column 165: ID jsf_tree_64 already defined. The above will not be fixed -- this element must exist and be submitted in every form.

Re: Standardcompliance of rendered markup

2007-04-03 Thread Mike Kienenberger
Jorn, I don't know if the id is required by the spec or not. Or if there's some reason why it's required by the MyFaces implementation. If you want to look into that and report back on your findings, maybe we can consider changing it. I know that identical hidden fields must be present for