Hi Gordy!  Good question about max number of 2.4 transmitters.  I seem to 
recall we exchanged some notes on this.
 
To answer your question, I never thought the number of concurrent transmitters 
was unlimited.  Frequency control and channel conflict are handled by the 
radios, so I don't have to manage it manually.  And all makers, except Futaba, 
have been pretty public about the max number supported by their particular 
implementation.  
 
And I doubt the average 2.4 user has given much, if any thought, to the max 
number of concurrent transmitters.  I would bet the typical RC user will likely 
never see more than 20 transmitters in use at once unless they are contest 
flyers, which most are not.  Even then, I would bet most contest flyers would 
rarely see the need for more than 40 on at once.  The largest contest  I have 
ever attended had 42 pilots, almost all were on 72 Mhz.  In this case, there 
were no channel conflicts.  Yet I doubt there were ever more than 20 sets on at 
one time.
 
The Heli event was a big exception but even with that we don't know if there 
were even 50 transmitters on at once, only that there were 500 transmitters at 
the site.  Until we start to see more events like this, it is going to be a 
while before we know if the max number of transmitters is even an issue, only 
that there are apparent limits by brand.
 
Gordy, you attend a lot of contests, some of which are quite large.  Why don't 
you organize a test at one of the upcoming contests.  See if you have enough 
2.4 sets to run a saturation test.  I would be very pleased to hear the results 
of that test.
 
Ed Anderson
LISF

> Date: Tue, 25 Dec 2007 21:15:00 EST
> From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
>> Subject: "Jack Benny is 39 and 2.4 is 38?"
> > 
> Number of systems that can be in use simultaneously 
> Spectrum Airtronics Futaba Xtreme
> 39 ................ 38 ......(?) ....? 120
> 
> Correct me if I am wrong but I believe the general modeler 
> believed that with 2.4 all concerns for freq control were over....Millions 
> could all be on at once...there was the story about the huge heli event with 
> hundreds of attendees most enjoying the freedom of 2.4....hmmmn.
> 
> Did you all believe that the amount of 2.4 TXs on at once was 
> almost unlimited?
> 
> Gordy

Reply via email to