This is why I beleive ISPs who have a restriction should publish their address blocks which are NOT supposed to be sending mail directly out. It then becomes the recipient mail domain's responsibility if they choose to block on the information published.

In your small ISP case, you would not publish information, but say in comcast's or optonline they would publish them.


Speaking as someone who uses such a "Dynamically Assigned" IP, I can
tell you I'd be royally pissed if Adelphia started blocking outbound
port 25 traffic. Here's why:
I have a laptop running Linux that I use for most of my email
correspondance. I use sendmail on this machine as my outbound mail
server. Why?
I use this machine all over the darned place, and got *really* tired of
having to reconfigure my email client every time I go to a different
client site (I often visit 4-5 in a day).
So I set up IMAPs for my incoming mail, and by using 'localhost' as my
outbound mail server, I never have to change my config.
If ISP's started blocking port 25 outbound except to their servers, I
would then be forced to change my config every time I move my system. Only a few clicks, but aggravating just the same.


As it is, AOL drives me insane because I can't send mail from my Cable
Modem to AOL addresses because of their stoopid "Email originated from a
dynamically assigned IP address" filter.  So I have to bounce it off
another server when I send to AOHell (which, fortunately, is very rare).

As the admin for a small ISP, I don't block anything outbound because I
repect people's choice to do what they will with the connection they pay
for.  I do carefully review what comes _in_ on a regular basis, as well
as post what's allowed in and what's not on the systsem's website.  I
do, however, watch fo rthe obvious, like large spikes in smtp traffic,
or lots of outbound port 135 probes, and notify the affected luser of
the problem.  And I get cranky _only_ if they don't do the right thing,
or simply don't respond.





-------------------------------------------------------
This SF.net email is sponsored by: Perforce Software.
Perforce is the Fast Software Configuration Management System offering
advanced branching capabilities and atomic changes on 50+ platforms.
Free Eval! http://www.perforce.com/perforce/loadprog.html
_______________________________________________
Spamassassin-talk mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/spamassassin-talk

Reply via email to