I understand peoples' concerns about having an occupied building over the top of a car carousel/stack. I have seen business buildings built over a gas station (perhaps not the best design strategy). I have seen airport radar buildings constructed over an office (both of which were unsprinklered). I have seen plenty of mixed use buildings, and though it may not make sense to do have mixed-use where the cost of land is minimal, the fact remains, in many cities and suburbs, urban planning and that ' green thing ' have designers taking a second look. It no longer is a foregone conclusion in dense urban areas that simply paving another parking lot or committing a lot to a single-occupancy building is in everyones best short, and certainly long-term interests.
We can design parking stacks underneath buildings safely. The several day ordeal in putting out a standard subterranean car park in Paris recently highlights the need for coordinating their design with fire departments (i.e. standpipes, vehicle access in low ceiling spaces, etc.). Stacked car subterranean parking is coming to dense urban centers. It makes efficient use of space. And there is a great way to protect these spaces without sprinklers. Geir Jensen and friends engineer a low-oxygen environment whereby the fire has a difficult time to start down there, let alone burn. The car carousel obviates the need for people, so long term exposure to 15% oxygen is not a problem. Nor is it something that a mountain man is not already used to. Most people can readily tolerate it for bouts of an hour or two. While this low-oxygen system is intrinsically safe... (even if power to the filters fails, the diffusion time needed to raise these 15% oxygen levels can be on the order of half days and longer where cars are remote from ambient air)... a substantial fire barrier between subterranean car-carousel and mixed-use occupancy above will provide a substantial and a second intrinsically-safe fire protection system. These car-carousel systems are good use of urban space; fire protection should embrace them. Good urban planning trumps fire protection. Fire protection is easy enough to acquire. Urban planning however, is much more difficult to make happen because city hall gets bought and caught by developers' dollars. In an effort to catalyze more and better urban planning, (planning that usually involves more mixed-use neighborhoods which are a hallmark of most evolved older-and-larger cities), fire protection need continue with its creativity and ramp up its motivation for finding better ways to make mixed-use happen. We should be helping mixed-use urban planning succeed, instead of offering prescriptive "no's" and SOP dead-ends. And it is not just fire protection...the EPA needs to get on its good foot. EPA regulatory wheels can grind slow, but it is time for them to let go of the idea that 15% oxygen is a problem, and instead embrace an intrinsically green solution ready to go in the starting gates. Perhaps to help let their fears go, a gravy-train conference in La Paz or Frisco, CO will butter their bread. scot deal excelsior fire engineer On Mon, Mar 1, 2010 at 16:57, Dan Wilder <[email protected]> wrote: > http://www.bre.co.uk/newsdetails.jsp?id=618 > > http://www.bre.co.uk/page.jsp?id=2149 > > > http://www.bre.co.uk/filelibrary/pdf/rpts/BRE_Global_Client_Report_no_signatures.pdf > > These are some reports done by the boys across the pond....if it helps. > > _______________________________________________ Sprinklerforum mailing list [email protected] http://fireball.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum For Technical Assistance, send an email to: [email protected] To Unsubscribe, send an email to:[email protected] (Put the word unsubscribe in the subject field)
