Spent the day surveying and talking to the Owner. These are moderate-rate 1600-2000 SF units, 5-700K, with a two-tiered deeded space. Problem is, the unit Owner has to buy the lift, building Owner isn't buying anything, just leaving a disconnect on the wall. Great. I told him I can't pipe for possible future lift like the wire nuts are, not just because there are dozens out there, but can't leave a head 5' of the floor sitting in space. I did go visit a new Hotel downtown, high-end, that I did some commissioning work on last year. They have about 200 lifts, run and handled by Condo Owner residents and parking attendants for the Hotel portion of the building. They did just what I was thinking, overhead system with a drop to a sidewall with a baffle and cage. So for now, I don't have to sweat the logistics or try and persuade a model be run. Plus, this guy wouldn't even pay the extra for concealed heads upstairs so I'm sure he won't pay the discount PE to have it farmed out to an FPE for fire modeling. I am going to add a tee and plug and leave it at that, my dime. It's funny (scary funny) as I started to imagine the scenarios you all shared and read your responses when I got back. Some serious loading is present in situations like this and I wonder if the FPE who did that hotel considered this. I only walked one level but it was mostly high-end vehicles jammed in, some just barely clearing the overhead system with not much more than 2' between lifts. The more I think of what Chris is writing the more relieved (for now anyway) I am. The hotel system was dry and a big dry system, at least mine is wet. Wondering of that little baffle would really make a difference.. Tom
I've fought both as a FF and I can't quantify it but there is a BIG difference in car fires vs. boat fires. Car fires are really not that challenging. I haven't seen boats under sprinklers but have seen a few cars. In a typical car under OHI design the neighboring car does not become involved. Worst I saw was melted tail light. Over/under would make a little difference I'm sure but my gut tells me to just increase density and you will loose both cars but not the ones next to the origin. I wouldn't bet my lunch on the SW idea alone, but you do know there are ECOH SW. My concern is when does it go off. If you are assured it's before the upper car is involved then fine. But the other problem is if the upper cars starts and the drop down of burning materials that involve the lower. Does the SW even go in this scenario? >From a purely simplified approach I like throwing density at most problems. This seems to be the solution in NFPA 13 for all but PODS, boats and fireworks. My suspicion is density works here too but no one has tried high enough. Chris Cahill, P.E. _______________________________________________ Sprinklerforum mailing list [email protected] http://fireball.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum For Technical Assistance, send an email to: [email protected] To Unsubscribe, send an email to:[email protected] (Put the word unsubscribe in the subject field)
