Le 20. 06. 18 à 19:23, osm.tagg...@thorsten.engler.id.au a écrit : > In places where there was only a highway=bus_stop node, this is often now > dual tagged with public_transport=platform as well (which is correct). > In places where there was only a highway=platform way/area, this is often now > dual tagged with public_transport=platform was well (correct too).
I agree, no issue with that > But in places that have both a highway=platform and a highway=bus_stop, dual > tagging both with public_transport=platform is wrong. The two should be > merged into only a single way/area with public_transport=platform. The > problem then is that you can't really dual tag that anymore, because the > highway=platform and highway=bus_stop tags are in direct conflict and can't > be tagged on the same object. > And because the lack of rendering in osm carto, many people are not going to > use PTv2 properly in this case, because they can't dual tag it so that it > will properly show up on the map. the best way to handle this with PTv2 and still have something render is to have highway=platform public_transport=platform on the way and move the highway=bus_stop public_transport=stop_position on a node part of the road. with this, you have only one plateform, one stop_position and no render issue. > Implementing public_transport=platform rendering purely as a 1:1 replacement > of highway/railway=platform, without properly supporting it as a replacement > of bus_stop, tram_stop, and so on is not going to fix that issue. Render the most commun used public_transport=platform in stead of the old less common used highway=platform is still a improvement I thing. it 'll not solve the whole mess, but it's a first good/easy step. _______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
