I agree with others that setting up a long list of services is probably unworkable, and would prefer to focus on population cut offs as the key criterion, with secondary, minor consideration to a very short list of key services. However, can we focus on what the key cut offs are before we discuss the fine details of scoring extra services? Once we’ve decided on the population cut offs it could be relatively simple to use overpass queries to see how often population cut offs address most of the service issues anyway (because doctors etc tend to be in bigger centres) and how often we have anomalies. Then we can work out scoring systems to address the anomalies. Until we agree on broad population-based categories we can’t move forward much imo. Thanks again Andrew for all your work and info, and everyone else for input. Cheers Ian _______________________________________________ Talk-au mailing list Talk-au@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-au
- Re: [talk-au] Classifying settlements (Was Re: Filling ... Warin
- Re: [talk-au] Classifying settlements (Was Re: Filling ... Andrew Davidson
- Re: [talk-au] Classifying settlements (Was Re: Filling ... Graeme Fitzpatrick
- Re: [talk-au] Classifying settlements (Was Re: Filling ... Warin
- Re: [talk-au] Classifying settlements (Was Re: Filling ... David Bannon
- Re: [talk-au] Classifying settlements stevea
- Re: [talk-au] Classifying settlements (Was Re: Filling ... Andrew Davidson
- Re: [talk-au] Classifying settlements (Was Re: Filling ... cleary
- Re: [talk-au] Classifying settlements (Was Re: Filling ... Andrew Davidson
- Re: [talk-au] Classifying settlements (Was Re: Filling ... cleary
- Re: [talk-au] Classifying settlements (Was Re: Filling ... Little Maps
- Re: [talk-au] Classifying settlements (Was Re: Filling ... Little Maps
- Re: [talk-au] Classifying settlements (Was Re: Filling ... stevea
- Re: [talk-au] Classifying settlements (Was Re: Filling ... Graeme Fitzpatrick
- [talk-au] Fwd: Classifying settlements (Was Re: Filling... Graeme Fitzpatrick
- Re: [talk-au] Fwd: Classifying settlements (Was Re: Fil... Little Maps
- Re: [talk-au] Fwd: Classifying settlements (Was Re: Fil... Andrew Davidson
- Re: [talk-au] Fwd: Classifying settlements (Was Re: Fil... cleary
- Re: [talk-au] Fwd: Classifying settlements (Was Re: Fil... Warin
- Re: [talk-au] Fwd: Classifying settlements (Was Re: Fil... Little Maps
- Re: [talk-au] Classifying settlements (Was Re: Filling ... Warin