Explica también si has tenido en cuenta los dos territorios insulares o estás hablando sólo de la península.
Saludos 2018-05-11 8:07 GMT+01:00 Jorge Sanz Sanfructuoso <sanc...@gmail.com>: > Buenas > A ver sobre el mapa que adjuntas me choca bastante. Una cosa es bajar > clasificación a las carreteras que van al lado de autovías y otra cosa es > pasarlas a tertiary. Que tenemos en españa tertiary sin linea en medio y > sin arcenes y vamos a igualar carreteras nacionales que en muchos casos > tienen un arcen considerable y siguen en buen estado. > > A parte me choca en Soria que la variante la pongas como tertiary. No la > conozco esa parte pero vamos una variante de una ciudad, que parece que no > tiene cruces a nivel me choca muchísimo como tertiary. > > ¿Puedes explicar claramente los criterios seguidos para dibujar el mapa? > > Un saludo. > > El vie., 11 may. 2018 a las 0:35, yo paseopor (<yopaseo...@gmail.com>) > escribió: > >> Buenas gente >> >> Al hilo de lo que dije en un anterior correo me gustaría informaros que >> estos días en la lista de correo de tagging se está debatiendo sobre las >> unclassified (un usuario planteaba que sus unclassified...tenían >> referencia, lo que va en contra de la misma definición de "no >> clasificada". Pues bien, al explicar la situación española en la que las >> categorías de OSM no encajan exactamente en la clasificación administrativa >> en algunos casos se han dado respuestas interesantes que para los que no >> seais de la lista de tagging os hago llegar: >> >> Martin Koppenhoefer dieterdre...@gmail.com via openstreetmap.org >> >> in Germany and Italy (and probably some more places) the difference is >> between a road section without grade level intersections (and with ramps) >> vs not. Trunk is used in these areas for roads that are built to a standard >> similar to a motorway but not legally designated as motorway. It is not >> about access restrictions (there is the orthogonal motorroad=yes property >> for this). >> >> Kevin Kenny kevin.b.kenny+...@gmail.com via openstreetmap.org >> >> One issue is that we have the "UK English is the language of tagging" >> rule - which widely gets interpreted as "highway classification must be >> force-fit into the UK system." The US system presents a complex problem for >> this, since most highway classification is delegated to the states, and >> they all have their own local schemes. >> >> In many counties in the US, rural roads are unnamed and have only >> reference numbers. A farm road may be "County Road 2200N" (which is a >> different classification from, say, "County Highway 23", and typically >> shown only on small blade signs, not banner signs) or "State Farm and >> Market Road #2134". As I understand it, it would fit pretty closely with >> what "unclassified" roads - which are a formal classification in the UK! - >> are understood to be. >> >> Near where I live, numbered 'US', 'State' and many 'County' roads do NOT >> reflect the governing body - they are all managed by the state department >> of transportation. Historically, they had other structures, but >> responsibilities were reallocated. The 'US' highway numbers are coordinated >> with neighbouring states, but the administration is by the state. There >> are also numbered but (nearly) unsigned 'reference routes' also maintained >> by the state to 'State' highway standards. I say 'nearly' unsigned because >> they do often have inconspicuous chaining markers with their numbers. >> >> Rather than labeling the governing body, the 'US', 'State' and 'County' >> designations around here reflect the grade of importance, expected level of >> traffic and expected quality of maintenance. Given that the designation >> reflects relative importance rather than administrative jurisdiction, >> despite the labeling, I'm comfortable with having US, State, and County >> numbered roads be 'primary', 'secondary' and 'tertiary' - but in the places >> where the counties number virtually every road, there is a need for a tier >> below 'tertiary' - and 'unclassified' seems to be it; it's a working >> category that might otherwise be 'quaternary.' >> >> Salut i mapes >> yopaseopor >> >> PD: Me he mirado un poco el mapa de la "piel de toro" y he "pintado" como >> quedaría el mapa de la Red de Carreteras del Estado si se aplicara la >> propuesta que propuse. Y ya que estamos os sugiero que hagais lo propio, en >> breve podríamos tener un inventario o un mapa del trazado y categoría >> "real" que podrían tener las carreteras nacionales en nuestro país. Aquí os >> lo adjunto. >> >> https://i.imgur.com/SicS3Gu.jpg >> _______________________________________________ >> Talk-es mailing list >> Talk-es@openstreetmap.org >> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-es >> > -- > Jorge Sanz Sanfructuoso - Sanchi > Blog http://jorgesanz.es/ > > _______________________________________________ > Talk-es mailing list > Talk-es@openstreetmap.org > https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-es > >
_______________________________________________ Talk-es mailing list Talk-es@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-es
