On 12 Apr 2009, at 9:01 , Adam Schreiber wrote: > > Probably because the mapper can easily identify the type of road (i.e. > Interstate, US Hwy, etc.). I'm not sure that the mapper should be > specifying the URL of the sign since it requires extra work to find it > and any renderer should be able to pick their own source of sign > shields (I know they can simply ignore the suggested one, but this > method can put more information into the DB).
ideally the renderer can figure out everything based on the ref tag and some tag or intelligent location lookup to find the state, county a road is in. It contains all you need to pick the correct sign. But you need the whole knowledge about signs for all states, county ... as an example California uses different signs for US routes but the same for interstates. State, county signs are different everywhere. And hey there is a world outside of US with even more variants. they will love local signs too! Adding a symbol tag is some work but doesn't harm if someone comes up with a heuristic in the renderer based on the ref, network, is_in, addr* tags and ignores it. a planet file is 102G uncompressed! does anyone care if we add ~ 1000 symbol tags for US? _______________________________________________ Talk-us mailing list Talk-us@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-us
