Randy wrote:

> Zeke Farwell wrote:
>
>>access=seasonal makes sense to me in conjunction with the date_on, and
>>date_off tags on the wiki.
>
> On and off aren't clear to me. Does on mean open or closed? Probably open, 
> but it isn't obvious, and might lose something in a language translation. 
> I think date_open=03-01 and date_closed=10-30 would be more clear, for, 
> for example the service road into a camping area. Maybe access=seasonal, 
> weather_dependent=yes or even access=weather_dependent for the closings 
> that are truly dependent on weather conditions and are not tied to a date, 
> like some mountain highways.

The on and off tags are clear if you don't invent a new, ambiguous tag
like "seasonal" and instead include the actual restriction.




_______________________________________________
Talk-us mailing list
Talk-us@openstreetmap.org
http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-us

Reply via email to