On Fri, Aug 28, 2009 at 4:18 PM, John Smith<deltafoxtrot...@gmail.com> wrote: > 2009/8/28 Norbert Hoffmann <nhoffm...@spamfence.net>: > >> No, Roy wants to tag the semantics of the stop-sign. If this really >> simplifies the task of the data consumers, it's all the better. > > It seems the problem Roy is trying to solve is to seperate lanes out, > of a dual direction way by use of a relation and pitting it against a > near by junction,
Pretty much. Not necessarily by use of a relation (my suggestion above was a tag only). But yes - the concept of direction is necessary for a stop sign because, as I said before, stop signs are generally not double-sided. > where this isn't the problem the needs to be solved, > each lane may have individual restrictions of one sort or another, now > instead of having 1 hacked up solution we now have 2, to describe how > a stop sign effects one lane out of a pair. > > The problem that needs to be solved is tagging individual lanes on a > way, regardless if the issue is a stop sign, different lanes have > different speed limits, different lanes having turn restrictions or > what ever the case may be, the problem is needing to tag individual > lanes. > > We should not be tagging stop signs and junctions with a relation that > doesn't solve the bigger issue. Stop signs stop you from entering a > junction and are before the junction and that's how they should be > tagged, however in this case traffic coming from the other direction > and in the other lane isn't effected by any stop sign. > > If we could tag lanes instead of ways this would be a no brainer, just > another speed bump of sorts, and in fact some speed bumps only effect > one lane, and they can be in pairs but at different positions on a way > and I bet they aren't being tagged properly either. So what are you proposing? How should we tag stop signs? To me, it seems you are suggesting that stop signs should *only* be tagged on ways that are oneway=yes. What are you proposing? _______________________________________________ talk mailing list talk@openstreetmap.org http://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk
