W dniu 03.12.2017 o 19:31, Yves pisze:
Because the discussion can be heated by the fear of seeing something 'disappear' from the map overnight.
Well, the fear might be there, but the discussion was already here, it was not too heated, and that was just my conclusions after the discussion. I also wrote the clear TL;DR summary that rendering should for now show everything - and then the criticism hit the list, when there was not declared to "disappear" anything, let alone over night.
So it has to be something different, I guess, and I still don't know what is it?
I don't have a particular idea concerning the orthogonals tags mentioned here. But it seems to me they could be discussed better as tags in a more general way, then the maintainers of osm-carto could propose with their own rendering choice.
That went just like you said: I came with the tagging problem triggered by designing rendering, we talked about the tagging problems, and I proposed my choice - one for tagging, the second one for rendering.
However it's not that easy nor productive to make everything separate. It was parallel discussion in the osm-carto ticket and the arguments were not heard on the list. Making more threads doesn't help to understand the problem and it's better to avoid it.
-- "My method is uncertain/ It's a mess but it's working" [F. Apple] _______________________________________________ talk mailing list talk@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk
