Mar 1, 2019, 11:48 AM by [email protected]: > > > > Am 01.03.2019 um 10:48 schrieb Mateusz Konieczny: > >> >> > ..... > > >> c) I recommend doing this, I tried mailing Mapbox about their >> license-breaking >> hiding attribution but at first their responded claiming that OSBL >> allows that, >> after quoting that part of them they went back to not responding >> >> d) what would be our options for especially stubborn ones? DMCA filed >> by OSMF? >> > > .... > > > Just to be clear on this, the OSMF licences use of OSM data and > derivates directly to the "end customer". In this case to the companies > that are using a third parties infrastructure to produce rendered maps > from OSM data. So while we can stipulate an ethical and moral obligation > of the third party to enforce attribution requirements, legally it is an > obligation of the website/service/whatever operator that is a customer > of the third party. > > Yes, I know that. But I guess that while it would have many harmful side effects and it should be used as a last resort I guess that Mapbox would react if they customers would start getting DMCAs. And anyway Mapbox itself is also hosting some maps that on mobile refuse to show proper attribution (despite that it would take less space than Mapbox logo that is displayed), so their example pages can be DMCAed. Additional question - who can file DMCA. AFAIK only OSMF can do that and individual mappers are unable to do it, right?
_______________________________________________ talk mailing list [email protected] https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk
