On Sat, 13 Dec 2003, Don Simons wrote:

>
> If a whole note is shifted to the left, then I agree. But if to the right,
> the proper distance depends on the width of whatever is in the way, and
> that's not necessarily another whole note. I can do it the way Olivier
> suggests, and it will cover chords of whole notes, but it will not cover all
> possible situations. Any comments?
>
I agree with Don that it is not sufficient to rely on the standard shifting
with r and e. In polyphonic music it is nearly always necessary to work with
X..S to obtain an optimal alignment. While this is indicated in the examples
of stampa musicale and its translations, it is not emphasized sufficiently.
However, there is a frequent standard
situation with whole notes that would justify the introduction of Olivier's
proposal: when two voices meet in unison, than one must write two whole notes
to indicate that because there are no stems.

Christof

_______________________________________________
Tex-music mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://icking-music-archive.org/mailman/listinfo/tex-music

Reply via email to