I suppose you can't really fault Wikipedia for saying "Linux" instead of "GNU/Linux".

I also once saw a writing style that gave more authority than deserved to Linus Torvalds, when combined with the tendency for "Linux" to be used to refer to GNU/Linux: "Among those critical of the new version is Linus Torvalds, the creator of Linux...". The statement is technically correct, but this was in an article about the whole controversy over GNOME 3,[0] which has nothing to do with the kernel of the system, which suggests that the only purpose of mentioning that he is the "creator of Linux" is to establish authority for his opinion by implying that he is responsible for the whole system.

What we really need is a "neutral" term, but this is problematic; you'd think that "GNU/Linux" would be neutral, right? When I saw "GNU/Linux" back when I thought that the whole system was Linux and created by Torvalds, seeing "GNU/Linux" just made me assume that "GNU" was another system similar to "Linux", and it never bothered me. Why the hell does it bother certain people so much, then? They say "Linux is popular", but "GNU/Linux" is a terminology choice which recognizes that.

Side note: I've thought about the naming thing quite a bit, and one possible term I kind of like is "Linux GNU". Everyone knows that "Linux" is some sort of software, not an organization (though many people wrongly think it's a whole OS), which is unfortunately not true about GNU (many people wrongly think that "gee-en-yew" is some sort of organization). With this, the only possible meanings for "Linux GNU" that I can think of are "Linux, which is a variant of GNU", or "the Linux variant of GNU". One of those is correct ("the Linux variant of GNU"); GNU/Linux is the GNU system with Linux as the kernel. Thought of another way, if someone produced an OS called "Linux BSD", it would be easy to understand that this is a variant of BSD using Linux instead of the BSD kernel. The only problem with "Linux GNU" is that other possible meaning; if too many people think that it means "Linux, which is a variant of GNU", they may drop the "GNU", thinking it's unimportant, but this would be avoided by a page explaining what it actually means.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Controversy_over_GNOME_3

Reply via email to