Alcaudon wrote: 
> Testing with my main TV (Samsung UE7000)
> 
> 1) 1080p and 720p work, but both have trimmed edges (same happens with
> my other TVs). With 1280x1024 skin the screen it's not trimmed, but
> there's no audio (this doesn't happen with my other TVs). I can easily
> switch between them. 
> 2) It reboots ok with the selected resolution.
> 3) Not sure if this is what you need:
> 
> > 
Code:
--------------------
  >   > 
  > [  147.595301] hdmi_video_present 1
  > [  147.598569] hdmi_3d_present 1
  > [  147.601550] hdmi_3d_multi_present 2
  > [  147.605640] hdmi_vic_len 0
  > [  147.608447] hdmi_3d_len 8
  > [  147.611105] HDMI 3d struct all =0x140
  > [  147.615259] HDMI 3d mask all =0x73f
  > [  147.618787] Support 3D video format
  > [  147.622298] vic_order_2d=4, 3d_struct=0, 3d_detail=0x0
  > [  147.627951] vic_order_2d=5, 3d_struct=0, 3d_detail=0x0
  > [  147.633137] vic_order_2d=9, 3d_struct=0, 3d_detail=0x0
  > [  147.638785] vic_order_2d=10, 3d_struct=0, 3d_detail=0x0
  > [  147.644411] CEA long desc timmings
  > [  147.647832] Aspect ratio: 16:9
  > [  147.650921]       148 MHz 1920 2448 2492 2640 1080 1084 1089 1125 +HSync 
+VSync
  > [  147.657584]
  > [  147.660507] Aspect ratio: 16:9
  > [  147.663579]       74 MHz 1280 1720 1760 1980 720 725 730 750 +HSync 
+VSync
  > [  147.669603]
  > [  147.672425] Aspect ratio: 16:9
  > [  147.675529]       74 MHz 1920 2448 2492 2640 540 542 547 562 +HSync 
+VSync
  > [  147.681499]
  > [  147.684363] EDID read returned : 0
  > [  147.688108] mxc_hdmi mxc_hdmi: same edid
  > 
--------------------
> > 
> 
> Hope this helps.

Thanks - is there any output before the bit you posted from the dmesg. 
For interest here's my panasonic TV:

Code:
--------------------
    
  Apr  5 22:18:28 wandboard kernel: [  216.154558] mxc_hdmi mxc_hdmi: same edid
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.868263] cea extent revision 3
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.871602] CEA underscan 0
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.874411] CEA basicaudio 1
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.877928] CEA ycbcr444 1
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.880653] CEA ycbcr422 1
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.883371] CEA Short desc timmings
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.887358] Tagcode 2 Len 16
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.890258] Support CEA Format #31
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.893674] Support CEA Format #16
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.897620] Support CEA Format #20
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.901041] Support CEA Format #5
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.904370] Support CEA Format #32
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.908251] Support CEA Format #19
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.911672] Support CEA Format #4
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.915387] Support CEA Format #18
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.918806] Support CEA Format #3
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.922135] Support CEA Format #17
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.926009] Support CEA Format #2
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.929343] Support CEA Format #7
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.932671] Support CEA Format #6
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.936692] Support CEA Format #1
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.940028] Tagcode 1 Len 3
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.942885] Audio Format Descriptor :  1
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.947283] Max Number of Channels  :  2
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.951225] Sample Rates            : 07
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.955580] Sample Sizes            : 01
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.959523] Tagcode 3 Len 7
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.962331] VSD hdmi capability 1
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.966121] VSD support ai 1
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.969020] VSD support deep color 48bit 0
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.973131] VSD support deep color 36bit 
1
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.977707] VSD support deep color 30bit 
1
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.981823] VSD support deep color y444 1
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.986266] VSD support dvi dual 0
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.989686] VSD MAX TMDS CLOCK RATE 190
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.993538] Tagcode 7 Len 3
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  219.996860] Not handle block, tagcode = 
0x7
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  220.001063] CEA long desc timmings
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  220.004899] Aspect ratio: 16:9
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  220.007973]       74 MHz 1920 2448 2492 
2640 540 542 547 562 +HSync +VSync
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  220.013607] 
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  220.016889] Aspect ratio: 16:9
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  220.019963]       74 MHz 1920 2008 2052 
2200 540 542 547 562 +HSync +VSync
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  220.025978] 
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  220.028800] Aspect ratio: 16:9
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  220.031869]       74 MHz 1280 1720 1760 
1980 720 725 730 750 +HSync +VSync
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  220.038204] 
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  220.050634] Aspect ratio: 16:9
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  220.053714]       74 MHz 1280 1390 1430 
1650 720 725 730 750 +HSync +VSync
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  220.059853] 
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  220.062673] Aspect ratio: 16:9
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  220.066227]       27 MHz 720 732 796 864 
576 581 586 625 -HSync -VSync
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  220.071518] 
  Apr  5 22:18:32 wandboard kernel: [  220.074363] mxc_hdmi mxc_hdmi: same edid
  
--------------------


I'm really trying to get a feel for whether there is a common format
which we can find which works on all TVs.  Is it possible there's a CEA
format list higher up the dmesg you posted?


------------------------------------------------------------------------
Triode's Profile: http://forums.slimdevices.com/member.php?userid=17
View this thread: http://forums.slimdevices.com/showthread.php?t=98544

_______________________________________________
unix mailing list
unix@lists.slimdevices.com
http://lists.slimdevices.com/mailman/listinfo/unix

Reply via email to