I wrote:

> Let me assume the pressure was a little higher than 1 atm. That means the
> fluid was pressurized and it was probably not steam. It was probably hot
> water.
>

Actually, a more realistic estimate would be that it is a mixture of hot
water and steam. So the flow meter error would be at least 3 and perhaps
more. Perhaps 6?

I realize this is a crude estimate. I believe that I.H. has better numbers
based on measuring the flow rate by other means. I have not seen these
numbers. I hope they are published eventually.

My point is that you do not need a gigantic error in the flow meter for
there to be no excess heat. The meter itself does not have to be wrong by a
factor of fifty to produce an apparent COP of 50 where the actual COP is
~1. A combination of errors from the flowmeter, temperature and pressure
readings is more likely. I think a flow meter error somewhere between 3 and
6 is not out of the question, especially given the Defkalion results.

- Jed

Reply via email to