On Nov 3, 2008, at 1:13 AM, Mark Iverson wrote:

Ed,
No biggee. And I didn't mean to insult your patriotism; what did I say that was untrue of religions
and also made you feel that way?

You seem to blame a religion for the actions of a few of its members. All religions have members who distort the basic views of their religion to justify their actions. It is very dangerous and, I suggest, anti-American to take this approach.


For the most part, I agree that sincere and informed people should be able to discuss politics w/o questioning a person's patriotism... However, there are many insincere people who use the sincere person's conscience and sense of fairness to manipulate and/or suppress their point of view. Do I think this is happening on this forum? No, but it is used quite extensively these days in many
venues and garb; it is insidious.

Agreed


I keep my mouth shut most of the time, so when I do open it, its usually based on facts, reason, and a reasonably well thought out position. And I admit that when I disagree with someone, my sarcasm tends to leak out... Hey, I'm human just like the rest of you characters.

RE: the policies of the current Republican administration...
Why is it that you and some of the other Vorts seem to completely IGNORE the fact that there is a bicameral Congress that also is responsible for what happens in this country???

These "facts" are ignored because Congress until recently was control by Republicans who shared the administration's view point. I admit that many Democrats also are equally to blame. Nevertheless, the policy starts at the top. The Bush policy was to let Congress and the free-enterprise system have freedom to do what ever they wanted. In addition, his policy was to send as much manufacturing overseas as possible and to reward such businesses with tax advantages. He also reduced taxes on the rich, who pay fewer taxes than expected anyway because of the many loopholes. His policy was simpleminded and extremely damaging to the country. Yes, Congress went along as anyone would expect them to do, which has gained them the unpopular rating. However, in any organization, a competent adult must be in charge, which was not the case for 8 years.

Not to mention the
FACT that this very same DEMOCRATICALLY controlled House & Senate have an approval rating that is
MUCH lower than the administrations???????????

The House has been controlled by the Democrats for only 2 of the last 8 years. This change occurred only because the Bush policies were so bad. It takes longer than 2 years to correct the damage especially when a veto is being used for the first time.


 The fact that I haven't seen these two FACTS even
get mentioned in all the political rants makes me wonder just how 'objective' you guys are when it comes to politics, thus, I see the political postings as just noise, and thus my rather blunt and sarcastic methods to improve the SNR. If you don't maintain the same level of openess and desire to consider ALL the facts when talking politics, then this isn't helping to resolve or solve or
enlighten anyone.

As I note above, the "facts" you state are not complete, hence do not count. I would ask why you would ignore the complete picture?


As you rightly point out, this doesn't seem to happen when the topic is science/techy. If you hope to have the political discussions help, then again, put them in a separate group dedicated to informed political discourse in the hopes that others who are interested in politics will see it and learn/contribute. The political discussions on this list, some of which are engaging and thought provoking, will inevitably stay right here... And anyone interested in a good political discussion
isn't likely to come to a fringe-science forum!

True, but this is the forum we have and some of us are concerned about subjects beyond science, some of which impact on science or on the ability to do science.


"Unless this discussion is done without excessive emotion and by using the facts..." Wholeheartedly agree. But as I pointed out above, there are some very simple and VERY obvious FACTS that do not get mentioned here; at least not prior to my doing so. Is this forum composed of only a socialistic/liberal viewpoint? If so, then political discussions are nothing more than preaching to the choir, and serving no 'positive' purpose but to make you all feel some sense of 'resonance'. :-)

I would like to suggest the labels such as liberal or socialist be avoided because the meanings have been so corrupted to be useless. Bush says he is conservative but his actions are not conservative. The Congress says they are not socialist but the bail-out is the most socialist action ever taken in this country. McCain calls Obama liberal as if that is bad. Obama proposes to do what has been done with taxes since the income tax was created, i.e. take from one group and give to another. The only issue is which group pays and which group benefits and by how much. This balance has always been changed as the need changed. Bush and McCain favor the wealthy (trickle- down), Obama wants to now favor the middle class (trickle-up). This policy would seem to have benefit to the country now that the Bush policy has been shown not to work very well.


RE: your comment about how politics will affect our lives as well as the ability to do science... Nearly all basic research is done by government agencies and academia; rarely does the business sector do applied, let alone basic research. Congress holds or strongly influences the purse strings for DOE, NSF, NASA, NOAA, DOD, DARPA, and any of the other govt agencies that spend money on science. If reason and objectivity were at work here, then you should be discussing how to reform (the currently democratic) Congress, not the president, and it should take aim at both parties. As far as academia is concerned, it is a bastion of liberal thinking, so if you're worried about how science is going to get done, I suggest you start addressing those that really control it, and stop
blaming the president.

Thanks to the failed policy, no money is available for new research and the budget for science is frozen. In addition, the Bush administration has been anti-science from the beginning. In addition, the appointed heads of many agencies have been political hacks who have not advanced science. This is not the fault of Congress. I detect a lack of understanding of how the government actually works. As for liberal thinking academics, I don't know what this means. Do you?


Can't wait for the electron to be over and we get back to science...

Agreed


No hard feelings, I hope!

No hard feelings as long as we can communicate without personal attack.

Ed

-Mark


-----Original Message-----
From: Edmund Storms [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Sunday, November 02, 2008 9:55 PM
To: [email protected]
Cc: Edmund Storms
Subject: Re: [Vo]:Colin Powell and Kareem Rashad Sultan Khan

OK Mark, I apologize for using the phase "as usual". Most of your posts are logical. However, in this case you not only made a statement that I know to be untrue about religions, but also insulted my patriotism. You have no understanding of my political views except I, like an increasing number of people, and apparently you as well, have discovered that the policies of the current Republican administration are a disaster. Sincere and informed people can and should discuss how the mess can be best cleaned up without questioning a person's patriotism. Unless this discussion is done without excessive emotion and by using the facts, we are not going to make any progress.

As for the discussion of scientific vs political subjects, the political is important now because it will affect all of our lives including our ability to do science. Unfortunately, on this list, the political subjects seem to generate personal attacks while the science does not. I'm sure once the electron is over, we will go back to the personally neutral subject of science.

Ed


On Nov 2, 2008, at 7:43 PM, Mark Iverson wrote:

Ed wrote:
"As usual, your emotions get the better of logic"

Tell me how logic supports your conclusion of "As usual" when
referring to my post?  To me, I'd have to have read at least 4 to 6
postings on a topic in order to feel like I would be justified in
using that phrase.  Obviously, you think one or two (very small
postings) are adequate.  From what I've been reading of your posts
(MANY more than 4 or 6 I might add) and others, there is a whole lot
more emotion in them than in mine… The level of contempt and
condescension in your postings toward the conservative viewpoint is
very strong and if you can't see that, then perhaps you should copy
some of your posts, delete your name from them and ask some people at
the local store to rate the emotion in them on a scale of 1 to 10.
Not whether they agree with them or not, just the emotional 'tone'…
might be enlightening.

In fact, there is very little emotion here. What prompted my post was
that the s/n ratio on this list is pretty much in the toilet right
now, again. Why don't you create a new list for political discussions
and keep this list for what it was meant.  That was my point… however
poorly stated.
Sorry about that… Or, take a vote, and if the majority of Vorts don't
mind the engaging political rants, then I'll not try to keep that
stuff out of here.

To answer your assumptions and comments…

I work in a company with offices all over the world, and with all
kinds of people, from diverse backgrounds and religions, and enjoy our
conversations and admire and respect their expertise.  I work closely
with at least 2 (former) Iranian citizens, and asked why they decided
to come here and become U.S. citizens... Care to know why?  One,
Farshid, even converted from Islam to Zoroastrianism.  Care to know
why?

My son-in-law has served three deployments in Iraq, and I'll take his
word for what the place was like before we got there and when he
left... And for how the average Iraqi citizen feels about our presence
there.  Frankly, I wish we weren't there at all…

I also realize that the extremists I referred to are a small # of the
muslim population, but you don't see the muslim leaders coming out in
strong opposition to the radical sects.  Why not?
Perhaps they are too afraid? That in itself speaks volumes...

You say that terrorist activity is not supported by the general
region.  Saudi Arabia has unlimited $ to help combat it, yet, are
they?  Not that I'm aware of.  In fact, there are some who think that
the Saudis are to some degree funding it.  Have they sent in any
equipment or security forces to help the Iraqi govt stabilize things?
Their other neighbor, Iran, is doing everything it can to encourage
the terrorist activities!  So I reject your premise that the region
doesn't support that behavior... And suggest that they could do a lot
more to help… but the leaders in that area  would rather build
extravagant artificial islands and palaces. How did they get all that
wealth?
Capitalism perhaps?

You said:
"We killed thousands and destroyed a society in an attempt to kill a
few people who might try to hurt us in the future"

And that former 'society' killed a hundred times that many (of it's
own people), so I guess your solution is to just turn a blind eye to
it… we haven't taken any goods from that country, just the opposite,
nor their pride.

Granted, I'm not nearly caught up on the 250+ posting that are still
unread, but I don't sense much 'love of country' in what I've read so
far…

As I've said before, I am no fan of the Bush admin, and am pretty much
fed up with most all politicians… they are more concerned about the
power struggle with the opposing party, and how to get back or
maintain power, than legislating in a responsible manner what's best
for the average citizen.  I have no doubt that this country would be
much better off if we eliminated the political parties altogether…
people and politicians might begin to put country first instead of
party.

-Mark


-----Original Message-----
From: Edmund Storms [HYPERLINK mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] ]
Sent: Sunday, November 02, 2008 4:40 PM
To: [email protected]
Cc: Edmund Storms
Subject: Re: [Vo]:Colin Powell and Kareem Rashad Sultan Khan


As usual, your emotions get the better of logic. First of all, not all Muslims are suicide bombers nor is this an action that is supported by the general region. Also, how do you separate this action from when we
operate when we bomb from the air? Of course, you can say that we are
trying to hit bad people, which we miss on occasion, but we are sorry
when innocent people are killed. We killed thousands and destroyed a
society in an attempt to kill a few people who might try to hurt us in
the future.  But this is ok with you because we are acting in self
defense, but the suicide bombers are not.  In fact, this is he only
way they have to fight us and the better armed countries that take
their goods and pride.

As for my acrimonious feelings about this country, you seem not to
understand the difference in feeling acrimonious about the actions of
the Bush administration and a love of country. Apparently you approve
of everything the administration has done. I hope you do not have a
mortgage and have a good job that stays in this country.  I will wait
to see how you feel in the future if past actions are not personal
enough to get your acrimony.

Ed

On Nov 2, 2008, at 4:55 PM, Mark Iverson wrote:

Gee Ed, I don't know any christians, buddists, scientologists or any
other belief systems that want to wipe out other belief systems;
that
would strap bombs on their children and handicapped, let alone 'sane'
adults, all in the name of their religion/god.

With all the acrimonious feelings you have about this country, sounds
like you'd be much happier in Iraq or Iran!  I'll buy your ticket...

-Mark


-----Original Message-----
From: Edmund Storms [HYPERLINK mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] ]
Sent: Sunday, November 02, 2008 2:38 PM
To: [email protected]
Cc: Edmund Storms
Subject: Re: [Vo]:Colin Powell and Kareem Rashad Sultan Khan

How do you tell the good Christians from the bad Christians, Richard?
Surely you know that bad Christians exist.  I suggest you use the
same method you would apply to Christians.

Ed



No virus found in this outgoing message.
Checked by AVG.
Version: 7.5.549 / Virus Database: 270.8.5/1761 - Release Date:
11/1/2008 7:56 PM

<winmail.dat>


No virus found in this incoming message.
Checked by AVG.
Version: 7.5.549 / Virus Database: 270.8.5/1761 - Release Date: 11/1/2008 7:56 PM


No virus found in this outgoing message.
Checked by AVG.
Version: 7.5.549 / Virus Database: 270.8.5/1761 - Release Date: 11/1/2008 7:56 PM



Reply via email to