Mark I agree with you. It is galling to hear Barrack Obama talk about
corruption, lobbyists and regulation when *he has* taken money from the
federal housing corporations.

No doubt they have the disgrace of an impeachment hanging over him to reign
in his powers.

However what I take objection to is maybe the lucky complacent type of black
man who by, maybe luck or environment looks down on other blacks as lazy
welfare bums. I've come to the conclusion that they are deeply self-loathing
about slavery (why didn't we fight back? The Jews suffer this too) and their
perceived lack of contribution to society. Or that they excel in sports and
music marks them as physical and somehow more primitive than the other
homo-sapiens on the planet.

I often used to row with my father about his ambivalent, ambiguous,
contradictory almost admiring way of dealing with racists. He seemed to be
forever holding out the olive branch as if to say 'we can change them, we
can improve to their standards'. I've come to the confidence of maturity now
where I don't have to prove myself to anybody or can deal with the
embarrassed looks when I meet the person I've been speaking to down the
phone for years (and hears a quite plumy English accent) and sees someone
who is 'black' (coffee actually).

Colin Powell is a hell of an example. You couldn't get more physical and in
your face than army life. He's rose through the ranks and has implemented
change: all (*all*) can serve their country.

Republican real-politik dissuaded him from the nomination back in 1999 and
he said his wife couldn't take the strain as 1st lady. Well she did OK as
the wife of the Chief of Staff. With respect it seems an excuse and someone
told him to stand down. What's more they made him the fall guy for "weapons
of mass destruction"

The republicans made a few token gestures with Condi who is a real brain box
and I'd bet we'd like to be a fly on the wall to hear the rows she's had.
However it is, really, only the democrats who are seizing the day and
entering into the 21st century with a massive statement of supporting the
most able guy, regardless of race.

I think Thomas Sewell and Walter Williams are just poster boys for the
right. "It's ok to speak about race we've got our frontmen". The more I see
it they complain too much, are self-loathing and are being used by
unreconstructed right-wingers who hide behind a philosophy that purports to
be fair and meritocratic. 

Their vision is one of unfettered dog eat dog. Their talk of meritocracy is
false and all the power will go to the well connected Ivy League boys and
people who bought their children a decent education, gave Daddy little boy a
hand up in the work place. It's all self perpetuating.

Digressing slightly, their passion for being 'objective' seems to have blue
(or ultra-violet) tinted glasses. When faced with irrefutable scientific
evidence about any issue opposed to *their* notions of personal liberty the
siren call goes up "big government, liberal fascism" and they find
themselves back peddling. (I like the one with Ayn Rand's novels being laced
with cigarette smoking characters whilst she rails on about Jazz clubs,
people taking drugs and the 60s counter-culture. So the legend goes, when
told by her doctor to stop smoking for scientific reasons she just stopped
by sheer force of will and hard work. Yeah right, I believe you.)

So despite the lies, the threat of impeachment and the dodgy economics, I
find Obama the best man. I get the same feeling about the Tories in the UK,
despite David Cameron who seems a very nice man (Eton-Oxford grandee); it's
still full of bigots. Several generations have to die out probably before it
can redeem itself. Then when the playing field is level we can discuss the
free market.

-----Original Message-----
From: Mark Iverson [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
Sent: 04 November 2008 07:24
To: [email protected]
Subject: RE: [Vo]:Colin Powell and Kareem Rashad Sultan Khan


For the most part I agree that most modern religions have decent goals and
try to teach people how
to behave in a society, and that it's the actions of a few zealous members
that give it a bad name,
but I was not thinking of that when I wrote what I did... But you seem to
think that its never the
religion.  If you want to qualify that with the term, "mainstream"
religions, then I would agree.
However, there have been belief systems that I would consider dangerous.  In
addition, there are
instances where the leaders of a religion are culpable in the actions that
are contrary to what the
institution preaches.  A perfect example is how the Vatican had at first
refused to acknowledge the
problem of pedophiles in the ranks, and it was only due to considerable
pressure from hi-profile
cases that it finally admitted, barely, to a problem.  This does nothing but
destroy the people's
faith in that institution...  I've also heard that more people have died in
wars fought over
religious disputes as opposed to territorial ones... And those wars were
likely supported or
condoned by the leadership.  It's not so cut and dry Ed.  

Also, I hope you aren't accusing me of being anti-american, since that would
make you a hypocrit.  I
would think you'd be more careful with what you yourself have experienced
due to your involvement
with CF/LENR!  That statement is bordering on the same kind of tactic that
the mainstream physicists
used with many of your CF colleagues... 

"I admit that many Democrats also are equally to blame."
Great, now we're getting somewhere; at least your willing to admit that both
parties are part of the
problem...

"Nevertheless, the policy starts at the top.  The Bush policy was to let
Congress and the
free-enterprise system have freedom to do what ever they wanted...[snip]"

Pretty much the usual liberal/democrat talking points... Well, I'll take the
opinion of Dr. Sowell,
an accomplished, self-made black-american economist over a scientist. To
quote him:
======================== BEGIN QUOTE ========================
>From Dr. Thomas Sowell...
(http://townhall.com/columnists/ThomasSowell#ColumnistBio)

Fact Number One: It was liberal Democrats, led by Senator Christopher Dodd
and Congressman Barney
Frank, who for years-- including the present year-- denied that Fannie Mae
and Freddie Mac were
taking big risks that could lead to a financial crisis. 

It was Senator Dodd, Congressman Frank and other liberal Democrats who for
years refused requests
from the Bush administration to set up an agency to regulate Fannie Mae and
Freddie Mac. 

It was liberal Democrats, again led by Dodd and Frank, who for years pushed
for Fannie Mae and
Freddie Mac to go even further in promoting subprime mortgage loans, which
are at the heart of
today's financial crisis. 

Alan Greenspan warned them four years ago. So did the Chairman of the
Council of Economic Advisers
to the President. So did Bush's Secretary of the Treasury, five years ago. 

Yet, today, what are we hearing? That it was the Bush administration's
"right-wing ideology" of
"de-regulation" that set the stage for the financial crisis. Do facts
matter? 

We also hear that it is the free market that is to blame. But the facts show
that it was the
government that pressured financial institutions in general to lend to
subprime borrowers, with such
things as the Community Reinvestment Act and, later, threats of legal action
by then Attorney
General Janet Reno if the feds did not like the statistics on who was
getting loans and who wasn't. 

Is that the free market? Or do facts not matter? 

Then there is the question of being against the "greed" of CEOs and for "the
people." Franklin
Raines made $90 million while he was head of Fannie Mae and mismanaging that
institution into
crisis... 
[Article continues but I think you get the point.... Or not]
======================== END QUOTE ========================

Next Ed says:
"As I note above, the "facts" you state are not complete, hence do not
count.  I would ask why you
would ignore the complete picture?"

Not ignoring it Ed, but now that we agree on the fact that there's enough
blame to go around for
both parties, how do we fix it?  What's the solution?  Even if BO does get
elected, he's not going
to make that much difference.  I would propose that without term limits,
there is no hope for real
change...

"Bush says he is conservative but his actions are not conservative. The  
Congress says they are not socialist but the bail-out is the most  
socialist action ever taken in this country."

No arg from me with those statements! Well, almost none.  The entire
entitlement system is probably
the biggest socialist action taken in this country... But agree that the
bailout comes in a close
second!  I would think that you'd support it since the majority of people
who will benefit will be
those in the lower income brackets...

"Obama proposes to do what has been done with taxes since the income tax was
created, i.e. take from
one group and give to another.  The only issue is which group pays and which
group benefits and by
how much..."

You open up a whole can of worms that I know a canful about... But perhaps
some other time.  The
history of the income tax is a very interesting read...

"Bush and McCain favor the wealthy (trickle- 
down), Obama wants to now favor the middle class (trickle-up).  This  
policy would seem to have benefit to the country now that the Bush  
policy has been shown not to work very well"

The diff between us is that, even though giving lip service to enough blame
oto go around, there is
absolutely no mention of specifics in any of your posts that I can
remember... It's all Bush's
fault!  I reject that, as does Dr. Sowell; Congress has more influence on
the domestic economy that
the prez ever will, and that's the way it should be.

RE: you comments on budget for science being frozen. 
>From the govt's own statistics, the budget for science has had modest
increases thruout Bush's admin
except for the yr-2008 estimate... How much should we be spending in
science?  Isn't $50 Billion
enough?  And I love science... I challenge you to change your mindset, and
instead of a constant
increase, why not work on reducing the overhead and implementing other
intelligent ways to run large
organizations!  Can you say, Spaceship One/Scaled Composites?????  A very
good example of the fact
that the private industry can do most anything MUCH MORE cost effectively
than government...
 
                                2004            2005            2006
2007            2008

        
estimate
estimate
Department of Defense   61,510  66,467  69,323  71,755  69,856
Other national defense  3,835           4,179           3,720
3,726           3,079
Total national defense  65,345  70,646  73,043  75,481  72,935
                                
Non-defense
General science, space, and technology:
NASA                            8,037           6,880           6,807
8,438
9,445
NSF                             3,439           3,638           3,707
3,943
3,894
Atomic energy gen'l sci 2,701           2,809           2,966
3,013           3,192
Subtotal                        14,177  13,327  13,480  15,394  16,531
Energy                  1,387           1,272           1,156
1,241           1,409

Transportation:
NASA                            551             834             722
736             669
DOT and Other           571             472             588             590
512
Subtotal                        1,122           1,306           1,310
1,326
1,181
                                
Health:
NIH                             24,498  26,039  26,695  26,974  27,580
Other                           1,726           1,541           1,570
1,554
1,558
Subtotal                        26,224  27,580  28,265  28,528  29,138
Agriculture                     1,694           1,758           1,779
1,795
1,734
Nat'l resources/envir   1,612           1,878           1,529
1,633           1,699
All other                       1,818           2,079           2,233
2,743
2,384
Totak NON-defense               48,034  49,200  49,752  52,660  54,076


-Mark


-----Original Message-----
From: Edmund Storms [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
Sent: Monday, November 03, 2008 7:24 AM
To: [email protected]
Cc: Edmund Storms
Subject: Re: [Vo]:Colin Powell and Kareem Rashad Sultan Khan


On Nov 3, 2008, at 1:13 AM, Mark Iverson wrote:

> Ed,
> No biggee. And I didn't mean to insult your patriotism; what did I say 
> that was untrue of religions and also made you feel that way?

You seem to blame a religion for the actions of a few of its members.   
All religions have members who distort the basic views of their religion to
justify their actions.
It is very dangerous and, I suggest, anti-American to take this approach.
>
>
> For the most part, I agree that sincere and informed people should be 
> able to discuss politics w/o questioning a person's patriotism... 
> However, there are many insincere people who use the sincere person's 
> conscience and sense of fairness to manipulate and/or suppress their 
> point of view.  Do I think this is happening on this forum?  No, but 
> it is used quite extensively these days in many venues and garb; it is 
> insidious.

Agreed
>
>
> I keep my mouth shut most of the time, so when I do open it, its 
> usually based on facts, reason, and a reasonably well thought out 
> position. And I admit that when I disagree with someone, my sarcasm 
> tends to leak out... Hey, I'm human just like the rest of you 
> characters.
>
> RE: the policies of the current Republican administration...
> Why is it that you and some of the other Vorts seem to completely 
> IGNORE the fact that there is a bicameral Congress that also is 
> responsible for what happens in this country???

These "facts" are ignored because  Congress until recently was control by
Republicans who shared the
administration's view point. I admit that many Democrats also are equally to
blame. Nevertheless,
the policy starts at the top.  The Bush policy was to let Congress and the
free-enterprise system
have freedom to do what ever they wanted.  In addition, his policy was to
send as much manufacturing
overseas as possible and to reward such businesses with tax advantages. He
also reduced taxes on the
rich, who pay fewer taxes than expected anyway because of the many
loopholes.  His policy was
simpleminded and extremely damaging to the country. Yes, Congress went along
as anyone would expect
them to do, which has gained them the unpopular rating.  
However, in any organization, a competent adult must be in charge, which was
not the case for 8
years.

> Not to mention the
> FACT that this very same DEMOCRATICALLY controlled House & Senate have 
> an approval rating that is MUCH lower than the 
> administrations???????????

The House has been controlled by the Democrats for only 2 of the last
8 years. This change occurred only because the Bush policies were so bad. It
takes longer than 2
years to correct the damage especially when a veto is being used for the
first time.


>  The fact that I haven't seen these two FACTS even get mentioned in 
> all the political rants makes me wonder just how 'objective' you guys 
> are when it comes to politics, thus, I see the political postings as 
> just noise, and thus my rather blunt and sarcastic methods to improve 
> the SNR.  If you don't maintain the same level of openess and desire 
> to consider ALL the facts when talking politics, then this isn't 
> helping to resolve or solve or enlighten anyone.

As I note above, the "facts" you state are not complete, hence do not count.
I would ask why you
would ignore the complete picture?
>
>
> As you rightly point out, this doesn't seem to happen when the topic  
> is science/techy.  If you hope
> to have the political discussions help, then again, put them in a  
> separate group dedicated to
> informed political discourse in the hopes that others who are  
> interested in politics will see it and
> learn/contribute.  The political discussions on this list, some of  
> which are engaging and thought
> provoking, will inevitably stay right here... And anyone interested  
> in a good political discussion
> isn't likely to come to a fringe-science forum!

True, but this is the forum we have and some of us are concerned about  
subjects beyond science, some of which impact on science or on the  
ability to do science.
>
>
> "Unless this discussion is done without excessive emotion and by  
> using the facts..."
> Wholeheartedly agree.  But as I pointed out above, there are some  
> very simple and VERY obvious FACTS
> that do not get mentioned here; at least not prior to my doing so.   
> Is this forum composed of only a
> socialistic/liberal viewpoint?  If so, then political discussions  
> are nothing more than preaching to
> the choir, and serving no 'positive' purpose but to make you all  
> feel some sense of 'resonance'. :-)

I would like to suggest the labels such as liberal or socialist be  
avoided because the meanings have been so corrupted to be useless.   
Bush says he is conservative but his actions are not conservative. The  
Congress says they are not socialist but the bail-out is the most  
socialist action ever taken in this country.  McCain calls Obama  
liberal as if that is bad.  Obama proposes to do what has been done  
with taxes since the income tax was created, i.e. take from one group  
and give to another. The only issue is which group pays and which  
group benefits and by how much. This balance has always been changed  
as the need changed.  Bush and McCain favor the wealthy (trickle- 
down), Obama wants to now favor the middle class (trickle-up).  This  
policy would seem to have benefit to the country now that the Bush  
policy has been shown not to work very well.
>
>
> RE: your comment about how politics will affect our lives as well as  
> the ability to do science...
> Nearly all basic research is done by government agencies and  
> academia; rarely does the business
> sector do applied, let alone basic research.  Congress holds or  
> strongly influences the purse
> strings for DOE, NSF, NASA, NOAA, DOD, DARPA, and any of the other  
> govt agencies that spend money on
> science. If reason and objectivity were at work here, then you  
> should be discussing how to reform
> (the currently democratic) Congress, not the president, and it  
> should take aim at both parties.  As
> far as academia is concerned, it is a bastion of liberal thinking,  
> so if you're worried about how
> science is going to get done, I suggest you start addressing those  
> that really control it, and stop
> blaming the president.

Thanks to the failed policy, no money is available for new research  
and the budget for science is frozen.  In addition, the Bush  
administration has been anti-science from the beginning.  In addition,  
the appointed heads of many agencies have been political hacks who  
have not advanced science. This is not the fault of Congress.  I  
detect a lack of understanding of how the government actually works.  
As for liberal thinking academics, I don't know what this means.  Do  
you?
>
>
> Can't wait for the electron to be over and we get back to science...

Agreed
>
>
> No hard feelings, I hope!

No hard feelings as long as we can communicate without personal attack.

Ed
>
> -Mark

No virus found in this outgoing message.
Checked by AVG. 
Version: 7.5.549 / Virus Database: 270.8.5/1764 - Release Date: 11/3/2008
7:46 AM
 



Reply via email to