On Jul 13, 2009, at 1:33 PM, Abd ul-Rahman Lomax wrote:

At 11:59 PM 7/12/2009, you wrote:

All said, I see the gaping hole in Takahashi's theory being the
orders of magnitude lack of detectable high energy alphas.   Perhaps
it is just a calculation error on my part.  It wouldn't be the first
time such a thing has happened.  8^)


It's the deafening silence regarding detailed comment on existing theories that strikes me.

Actually, a great deal of comment has been undertaken by the CMNS chat group. This group is made up of people in the field who know a great deal about the subject and do not have to be educated. In addition, I find that detailed discussion about theory does not go far because most of the critique involves assumptions that have not been and cannot be supported. These assumptions are generally unique to the theory and are defended to the death by the person proposing the theory.

Ed

Reply via email to