"Everyone knows the rules" Jed, do you have a copy of the rule book I could borrow, or at least let me know what page to look on?...
On Fri, Aug 2, 2013 at 3:10 PM, Jed Rothwell <jedrothw...@gmail.com> wrote: > Axil Axil <janap...@gmail.com> wrote: > > It would be ironically tragic if the guy who has spent the best part of >> his life supporting cold fusion and then LENR, did not recognize the >> personification of his goal when it was placed in front of him. >> > > I never "recognize" any claim until it has been replicated. That is the > rule. > > > It would be an even bigger tragedy if he fought against his goal’s >> realization. >> > > Who is fighting?!? That is ridiculous. I am saying they should release a > third-party evaluation if they want credibility. Anyone would say that. > Okay, maybe they do not want credibility, or they do not need it. But if > they do want it, they should publish a paper. A demonstration is a good > first step but it must be followed by a rigorous, third-party written > evaluation. They know that! Everyone knows the rules. I am not attacking > anyone when I point this out. > > > >> Anybody that agrees with Mary Y in any way needs to reevaluate his >> thinking processes. >> > > Even a stopped (analog) clock is right twice a day. It is not logical to > claim that every valid assertion must be opposite of whatever Mary Yugo > says. She does not get to set the agenda or decide what is logical. If I > reach a conclusion independently of her that happens to agree with her, > that means she is right. It does not mean I am wrong. > > - Jed > >
