On Tue, Jul 22, 2014 at 11:41 PM, Axil Axil <janap...@gmail.com> wrote:

What does a near-zero K temperature phenomenon have to do with LENR or the
> price of wheat?
>
> You are talking about a BEC of Rydberg atoms. That BEC is very heavy and
> can only happen at low temperatures. A BEC of Zero mass or near zero mass
> bosons can exist at vey high temperatures. So your inbreed assumptions are
> not correct.
>

Although I'm skeptical about the BEC stuff, I'm not saying you're incorrect
on this one.  I do think you have the burden of showing that such a
zero-mass or near-zero-mass BEC exists and is relevant to LENR.  In order
to be convincing, I think you would need to come up with a simple,
cost-effective experiment that we can all agree is falsifiable and that
will establish your claim.  It would not be enough to point to promising
articles on phys.org, as the starting points of such research are usually
too far removed from the kinds of systems we're interested in.

Eric

Reply via email to