On 11-05-18 2:46 PM, Aryeh Gregor wrote:
Also, we should be preserving inline styles.
We should copy all attributes and have a blacklist of uncopyable attributes.
ID is the only one I can think of off the top of my head that needs
blacklisting.

accesskey, itemid, and name (on<a>) seem potentially problematic too.
  It's also possible that custom attributes, data-* or otherwise, might
be issues, depending on how they're used.  I guess in that case it's
better to duplicate it and let authors figure out the consequences if
it's wrong, than to destroy the info about what attributes it
originally had.

I agree.

So probably it's okay to just blacklist id and<a name>.

What about itemid and accesskey? (There may be other examples that I'm forgetting right now).

IMO, WebKit's behavior here is wrong. When you hit enter not in a block
Opera's behavior here seems right to me. If I understand correctly here's
what Opera does:
enter without a parent block: wrap everything in two block elements as
defined by the opera-defaultblock execCommand.
enter with a parent block: split the parent block
shift+enter: insert a BR
enter inside a header: breaks out of the header and inserts a block as per
the opera-defaultblock execCommand (this is just legacy we're stuck with
from IE5+)

There's more magic than that.  For instance, if you're in an<li>  and
hit Enter twice, all browsers will create a new<li>  on the first
Enter and then destroy it and move you outside the list on the second
Enter.

Yes. Overall, this seems like a pretty sane basis on top of which we can build the algorithm.

Cheers,
Ehsan

Reply via email to