-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA512 On 08/09/2018 04:55 AM, Aryeh Gregor wrote: > The main problem here that needs to be solved is communicating > what the problem was in a manner that is clear to the parties whom > the CoC committee seeks to deter. A one-week ban is not going to > help anything if the object of the ban doesn't understand what > about his behavior elicited the ban.
This. Blocks should be preventative, not punitive[1]. If after a week is up, and the subject doesn't understand the problematic behavior, or has no intentions of fixing their behavior, then we're just going to find ourselves in another wikitech-l thread about the same issues a few months later. And I'd rather we not. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Blocking_policy#Blocks_should_be _preventative - -- Legoktm -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- iQIzBAEBCgAdFiEE+h6fmkHn9DUCyl1jUvyOe+23/KIFAltvy9kACgkQUvyOe+23 /KKMrBAAjpe/E0Pk91hK+jP6/OFNGhX5g+Po0q63yjyor2qKAxJk2EZJSad4hRK8 jK/jv223dgqmHYmmX3Sf4ZMmu42N8kL54eKvFraGyjNBCdNlINxf+KTO/KLJ+bO1 mmjZlua/fWaoYoeIv/dywJW5u4p2xA9H1hP/6RychlX+n6P+6R2dLK+JZSHts3Bg 6HWSFnl6OQZ2DrxuSiUoYkRj/syouGUEw0KWH3h/ScBpeWmhgd+PRS5wN0MVCsgW h5rLMcJ1PUN/uQ6g8qW0f11LYxjWvfQY8uPXbj1cP6jJHnpFtgtUHWzsfWhWKpyY /PT7i5gPMzibn6GiDCNm6bOMokWAC+b9aezeuYq8HhPOh10qo2tJwLJ0qPfixodX uJQeKDklb3rJVUl+M0dvN5xp54nfGjLxGd69fCAIuLBM4pKzAp2vyVKigbikTCcq 5nxpSn3sEg+/u8i/1X0mTI4z0IpfoZIwFGXJ8kZb3NWbJkW8ihI+mq/ZXwFc8RP4 TVtZOLzpRxeJoIppnf+108RutXAIV973kXGRIrpf9RKvq3yjykZzjUxoDYTaTZVv FszYuxiWmIo91EfrXffJ+nmfPMza2O3awJo6Yy6ffh5KSGjFG0iJGiNh1RdN3R3R gspxXaIBvyNj0AlqvVKJM72EUPZdxp+SiQpUecj2ssPya91AeyU= =WKSj -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- _______________________________________________ Wikitech-l mailing list Wikitech-l@lists.wikimedia.org https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikitech-l
