Hello Justin,
Could you please take a look at the previous thread by Josh and confirm our
LICENSE and NOTICE files so we can restart the vote.
Thank you very much,
Eya
On 2021/11/05 16:22:30 Josh Innis wrote:
> We have updated the NOTICE file to include the Bitnine copyright information
>
We have updated the NOTICE file to include the Bitnine copyright information
and removed the Postgres info as well, the Postgres license remains in the
LICENSE file, and the files with Postgres code now have the postgres header,
rather than the ASF header. These changes are all in the 0.6.0
Thank you, Justin. We followed your advice and redirected the download links as
requested. Also added KEY Files to the website.
**Changed
https://dist.apache.org/repos/dist/release/incubator/age/0.5.0.rc0/apache-age-0.5.0-incubating-src.tar.gz.sha512
to go via
I have updated the following files in question in my repository to use the
Postgres header, and removed the ASF header.
https://github.com/JoshInnis/incubator-age If this is correct we will correct
in the repository and the release as well. It includes the full copyright with
no mention of
Hi Justin,
So, we are going to put the PostgreSQL license into all of our files that have
any PostgreSQL code and remove the ASF license from them.
Additionally, going forward we are going to move as much of the PostgreSQL code
that can be moved, into their own files.
Will this satisfy your
Hi Justin,
I feel it is important to point out that we are constantly adding PostgreSQL
code to our project as we add in new components. A lot of our work is
transforming PostgreSQL's implementation to work with our added functionality
i.e. our work is very mixed with PostgreSQL code.
Hi Justin,
What is the ASF policy for including parts of external source files such as in
functions? Again, we only include what we need and we generally modify that
code. We don't copy files over, with the exception of one that I can think of.
In this case do we just use the PostgreSQL
That statement is contained with the LICENSE
https://github.com/JoshInnis/incubator-age/blob/master/LICENSE.
Postgres headers do not include it. Its only contained in the COPYRIGHT.
https://github.com/postgres/postgres/blob/master/src/backend/executor/execAsync.c
Hi Justin,
I setup my private github repository with the updates to the license headers.
https://github.com/JoshInnis/incubator-age
Can you please confirm that all files in question, with regards to Postgres,
should have the following header:
/*
* Licensed to the Apache Software Foundation
Hi Justin,
It would be accurate because, most of our code is based off PostgreSQL. AGE is
an openCypher language implementation built into PostgreSQL via their extension
mechanism. It follows how PostgreSQL implements the SQL language.
Additionally, we modify their parse and query trees in
Hi Justin,
Additionally, for -
"Also you need to think about all of the code that has been copied but probably
has incorrect headers."
Are you referring to a more general case of code other than PG or Bitnine?
Could you expand a bit on this please.
Thank you in advance!
John
On 2021/11/01
Hi Justin,
Most of our code uses or is inspired by PostgreSQL's code, in some modified
form or another. Additionally, we try to have our code work tightly with their
code in order to reduce replication of code. As a core developer, and from your
input, I wouldn't be comfortable with anything
12 matches
Mail list logo
