On Thu, 15 Jun 2000, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
> Not the same mag, but in a recent Jockey Slut, they had D&B dj's (LTJ
> Bukem, Jumpin' Jack Frost and some other guy) review 12's and they ripped
> on 'Revenge of the Jaguar', saying it was 'trying to re-create something
> that's long gone' (read Detroit) but also made sure to name drop lots of
> old tracks so we readers would know they were down back in the day. They
> also dissed Anthony Rother's excellent Little Computer People 12", citing it
> as a 'tired' and 'not progressive', which is a laugh coming from a guy who
> has made a career out of playing a Korg MS-1 pad over top of an uncut amen
> break ad nauseam.
I think they have a point. I'm not sure if it applies to KOTJ, but
it's a valid one nontheless.
If Bukem namedrops old 313 records, is he just 'trying to prove he was
down'? I think he _was_ down, played those tunes when they were released, then
went on to create his own style. Tunes like 'Demon's Them' and 'Horizons' are
serious landmarks in deep dance music. To dismiss them in terms of gear
is like slagging Red Planet tunes for always using old Roland kit. Can you
blame the originator of a powerful cliche for their clones?
I like jungle, but that's not my point. My point is that there is
such a thing as music getting tired, and there is such a thing as music moving
on. What got me into Detroit music was a sense of futurism, innovation, and
emotional truth, not 130 BPM+Juno pads.
Even some tunes that I like - Maas' "Juan is the Teacher" f'rinstance,
or Ian O'Brian's "Mad Mike Disease" - leave me wondering if they're helping or
hurting the music with their fetishistic recreation of the sounds of Detroit
c.a. 1989 or 1992. Anthony Rother is fun, but do we really need another person
rehashing a blueprint that was drawn almost 20 years ago?
So respect to those pushing the music forward. 99% of us on this list
aren't from Detroit. Respect to the legacy of the past and the integrity of
the present. After all, Juan Atkins didn't decide to make Motown remakes.
That moment was long gone.
J