First off, what a load of boll*cks.
What you are basically saying is that by "performing like a seal" you
are magically transformed from a good DJ to a great DJ - absolute utter
rubbish.
The case in point, Surgeon, he clearly speaks through his music and
that's the way he is, he doesn't perform but who actually does? Last
weekend I watched Karl scream Ov Power into his face from a couple of
mill away, he didn't bat an eyelid, it's who he is - and Karl is
completely the opposite - which is why it works. Now, we (S23) on the
other hand go nuts because it's the way we express ourselves - we even
go for when we practice because it's natural to us but don't think for a
minute that Surge isn't giving it 100%. It just a different way.
I think it's a crying shame that unless you do something like a two
step dance by the frigging Drifters you aren't a "great" DJ in your
eyes, that is just proper mentalist.
each to their own martin. but a dj that isn't involved with the crowd
just isn't doing their job.
don't get me wrong there are many ways in which a dj can be involved
with that crowd (just being _genuinely_ physically into the music is
_one_ way, see my original post) but i'm not saying that is the only
way. i've not seen surgeon play so assuming he does have the crowd
interested then he has a different method.
at no point am i saying that a dj has to fake the funk to get things
going (performing, as you put it, like a seal) but for me a dj fails if
the floor loses interest for a sustained period of time.
and to link this to the original point the source of the sounds is
immaterial, the intention of the dj is.
robin...
