Hi ravis...@gmail.com, Very nice reply from you, constructive criticism is something people don't know the meaning of or the need for....
same fellow who criticize so badly can do it only in the internet, becos he really can't say this is any real forum(a public meeting or even in a friends group for eg).Since internet is place where anyone can speak anything anywhere becos nothing will really hurt/cost them here. In reality, even though we are a democratic country,even an newspaper can't criticize anyone so badly. So why do we need to allow this to happen at "arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com", I dont understand. - Ravi A. On Wed, Aug 4, 2010 at 11:04 PM, ravi <ravis...@gmail.com> wrote: > > > There is a Nostradamus in our group and his name is Gomzy and if one would > check a mail from the very past where he replied to you when you were at the > peak of praising Enthiran after hearing a small bit, that speaks all. Gomzy > is right yet again. > Immature is not AR's music but the listeners who want him to repeat > Teekuruvi, and Thiruda Thiruda. > 1. A genius must understand that this is a soundtrack of a movie and the > songs are as what is required by the screenplay and the director. Probably > Shankar doesn't like Theekuruvi kind of a song though AR would have said > there is my loving fan who would like that kind of a song. > 2. Do you have any album which has entirely different electronica (with > robot sounds) which doesnt sound anything like the '80s? Would you mind if I > say please ask Honda to give some sound loops which would be 2010 Robot > pattern and that it doesn't sound like 80s. Majority of AR's current fans > were the kids of 80s please note this. > 3. You don't like him doing SDMish sounds do you like him to repeat older > songs, might be mesmerizing? You probably don't understand how fed up are > few members when they see your repeating mails. > 4. Do you think creativity is lacking? What exactly do you mean? Even God > has no creativity then, he keeps increasing humans who lack every possible > good things on this earth. > 5. Can you realize if a draft piece can be so great & appreciated how could > the final be? > 6. Pls get in touch with the one who wrote lyrics and I would appreciate if > you can say this to him directly. I would love to read your lyrics if you > can write for one. > 7. Definitely not. I am not a pessimist. > 8. You cant expect that kind of a track here unless Shankar would demand > one. > > Dont you think AR has done the song "amma Thalle" in the Theekuruvi style > just because one of his fan, that you have been loving it so much. Did you > any time give a thought about that? > > Now for all my friends. > Pls understand that AR reads our posts and just imagine what kind of a pain > are we giving for that person who is restless in entertaining us. He > respects this forum, he treats our opinions as genuine feedback and suitable > adapts his correction in the following album. Is this the kind of feedback > that we should be giving for such a great human. Understand the greatness of > his personality if not just for the music. If somebody has to give a > feedback or an opinion its welcome but definitely not the kind which insults > him or anything defamatory definitely not the one like what Arun Claus's > sick review was and atleast not the one like the earlier. > Dont you think that Ar has been changing & experimenting based upon what we > write here? Are we so harsh to our parents would you any time shout at your > mother saying her cooking was Kiddish and nothing great from what it was > since you had started to eat? > Give valuable feedback which gives more information and suggestion, if you > feel you are wasting money buying an AR album dont buy the next time its > released, please. I definitely dont like sugar coated, exaggerated mails > which I feel is written with an intention to draw attention of AR or his > associates at the same time dont write harsh just with the same intention. > This is my request, please. > > --- In arrahmanfans@yahoogroups.com <arrahmanfans%40yahoogroups.com>, > Taimur Nadeem <taimur.nad...@...> wrote: > > > > the most immature and outdated music by A R RAHMAN ever , is what my > review is of endhiran after listenig it quiet a few days now. > > > > 1) Not a single mesmerizing musical sound in the whole album. > > > > 2) what is 80s robotic music doing in 2010. A R RAHMAN is a revolutionary > in music how he could go back to that outdated sounds. i thought the maestro > will come up with a new ultra futuristic sound for robot but...... > > > > 3) what in the world has happened to A R RAHMANs music of songs, same > slumdog millionairish type sounds. i am fed up. > > > > 4) No song can be called a masterpiece in any sense. creativity lacking, > such songs and music is been heard many times before. > > > > 5) Seems to me songs were never worked out at all looks to me a draft > work was done and then released. > > > > 6) listen to the hindi version , O my GOD cant shankar hire a better > lyrcist , embarrassing lyrics. > > > > 7) Worst ALBUM of the Shankar AR R combo . > > > > 8) Sweetness is getting rarer n rarer in A R RAHMAN songs.the midas touch > is missing. > > > > KILIMANJARO AND KADAL ANUKKAL were the songs i liked but i getting bored > from them now .hope Gopal you post it . the storm praise is flooding for > what i dont know. Shankar HAS COMPLETELY directed RAHMAN sir wrongly. only > kids could like such an album. > > > > regards, > > > > taimur > > > > >
