The big problem I see here is that, intuitively, two o's are going to be
like 'u' as in good, book, room, oocyte, so on and so forth; but never as
what, how, awkard and so forth.














At 3:36 PM -0600 7/26/03, J Kalita wrote:
>Rajen da,
>
>There is nothing personal. I am looking at the merit
>of what both Shyamanta and you have proposed. The vowels
>seem to be the most difficult point and hence, I am looking at them
>carefully and critically. I am considesing only one situation here, others
>may
>have to raised later.
>
>Please explain to me the questions I raised in the previous message.
>
>Why should "noopoowa" (in Shyamanta's scheme) should be writen
>as "nwpwa" in your scheme and not as "nwpwwa"? Here,  "nw" is
>"no" followed by the w-kar (or oo-kar in Shyamanta's scheme),
>"pw" is "po" followed by the w-kar (or oo-kar in Shyamanta's scheme),
>and the last "wa" is the wabbo followed by a-kar.
>
>Jugal
>
>
>>
>> Jugal:
>> In this analysis, you are the judge and the executor too. First you have
>> not convinced me till now why we need transliteartion of one to one
>> Assamese letters. So what you guys are discusing and debating is within
>> yourselves.  I have already put my two cents. Whatever you do my only
>> request is please do not try to reinvent the Assamese language. Other
>> than that I think it is better that I do not take any part in your 1 to
>> 1 transliterartion process for which I fail to see any merit. Thanks
>> Rajen Barua
>> >From: J Kalita
>> >To:
>> >Subject: [Assam] Comparing Shyamanta and Rajen da's proposals head
>> to head  >Date: Sat, 26 Jul 2003 15:09:19 -0600 (MDT)
>> >
>> >Let's compare Shymanta's and Rajenda's ideas for
>> >the 5th and the 9th vowels. Here are some examples.
>> >
>> >1) dog = kukur (both Shyamanta and Rajen da)
>> >2) fire == jui (both Shyamanta and Rajen da)
>> >3) i will sit by fire == moi jui poowam (Shyamanta) moi jui pwam
>> (Rajen da)  >4) hug == akoowali loowa (Shyamanta), akwali lwa (Rajen
>> da)
>> >5) gamble = juwa (both Shyamanta and Rajen da)
>> >6) go now == etiya joowa (Shyamanta), etiya jwa (Rajen da)
>> >7) not get it == noopoowa (Shyamanta), nwpwa (Rajen da)
>> >8) (you) please eat = khoowa (Shyamanta), khwa (Rajen da)
>> >9) to burn = poora (Shymanta), pwra (Rajen da)
>> >10) (you) do not eat == nookhoowa (Shyamanta), nwkhwa (Rajen da)
>> >11) young cow or calf = goru poowali (Shyamanta), goru pwali (Rajen
>> da)  >
>> >Good points about Shyamanta's proposal
>> >----------------------------------------------------------
>> >Shymanata's maintains 1-1 mapping.
>> >Shymanta's proposal has no problems with either the vowels
>> >or the 'wabbo".
>> >
>> >Bad points about Shyamanta's proposal
>> >-------------------------------------------------------
>> >I don't see any.
>> >
>> >Good points about Rajenda's proposal
>> >------------------------------------------------------
>> >It seems to me that phonetically speaking, Rajenda's
>> >use of "w" is intuitive if it is directly followed by a vowel,
>> >as in "khwa" or "lwa".
>> >
>> >Bad points about Rajenda's proposal
>> >---------------------------------------------------
>> >A) The use of "w" by Rajenda seems unintuitive when the "w" is not
>> >followed by a vowel as in "nwkhwa" (the first "w" here is not
>> intuitive  >to me because it is not immediately
>> >followed by a vowel, whereas the second "w" is because it is
>> immediately  >followed
>> >by the vowel "a"). So, I doubt if the expressive power
>> >that Rajenda sees in "w" comes from a) the "w" itself, or
>> >b) the vowel that follows it, or c) from a combination of "w"
>> followed by  >the vowel.
>> >
>> >B) The spellings "nwkhwa", "nwpwa" are awkward to me, and possibly
>> >incorrect according to Rajenda's own scheme.
>> >
>> >A possible correction in Rajenda's transliteration?
>> >------------------------------------------
>> >Rajenda seems to ignore the trailing
>> >"wabbo" in some of his transliterations.
>> >Maybe, to express the last "wabbo" in such words, Rajenda should
>> spell  >them more correctly as "nw khw wa" or "nw pw wa".
>> >The last "wa" then represents "wabbo" followed by "a-kar". In that
>> case,  >the spellings become even more awkward. I wouldn't like to
>> type  >"nwpwwa" or "nwkhwwa" if I had a choice!
>> >
>> >-----
>> >
>> >I like Shyamanta's proposal better because of the considerations
>> >above unless Rajen da comes up
>> >with a way to distinguish between the use of "w" as a semi-vowel
>> >in transliteration and the useful
>> >Assamese letter "wabbo" in a more attractive manner.
>> >
>> >Jugal Kalita
>> >
>> >
>> >
>> >_______________________________________________
>> >Assam mailing list
>> >[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>> >http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam
>> Tired of spam? Get advanced junk mail protection with MSN 8.
>
>
>_______________________________________________
>Assam mailing list
>[EMAIL PROTECTED]
>http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam



_______________________________________________
Assam mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam

Reply via email to