Let's compare Shymanta's and Rajenda's ideas for
the 5th and the 9th vowels.  Here are some examples.

1) dog = kukur (both Shyamanta and Rajen da)
2) fire  == jui (both Shyamanta and Rajen da)
3) i will sit by fire == moi jui poowam (Shyamanta)  moi jui pwam (Rajen da)
4) hug == akoowali loowa  (Shyamanta),  akwali lwa (Rajen da)
5) gamble = juwa (both Shyamanta and Rajen da)
6) go now == etiya joowa (Shyamanta), etiya jwa (Rajen da)
7) not get it == noopoowa (Shyamanta), nwpwa (Rajen da)
8) (you) please eat = khoowa (Shyamanta), khwa (Rajen da)
9) to burn = poora (Shymanta), pwra (Rajen da)
10) (you) do not eat == nookhoowa (Shyamanta), nwkhwa (Rajen da)
11) young cow or calf = goru poowali (Shyamanta), goru pwali (Rajen da)

Good points about Shyamanta's proposal
----------------------------------------------------------
Shymanata's maintains 1-1 mapping.
Shymanta's proposal has no problems with either the vowels
or the 'wabbo".

Bad points about Shyamanta's proposal
-------------------------------------------------------
I don't see any.

Good points about Rajenda's proposal
------------------------------------------------------
It seems to me that  phonetically speaking, Rajenda's
use of "w" is intuitive if it is directly followed by a vowel,
as in "khwa" or "lwa".

Bad points about Rajenda's proposal
---------------------------------------------------
A) The use of "w" by Rajenda  seems unintuitive when the "w" is not
followed by a vowel as in "nwkhwa" (the first "w" here is not intuitive
to me because it is not immediately
followed by a vowel, whereas the second "w" is because it is immediately
followed
by the vowel "a").  So, I doubt if the expressive power
that Rajenda sees in "w" comes from a) the "w" itself, or
b) the vowel that follows it, or c) from a combination of "w" followed by
the vowel.

B) The spellings "nwkhwa", "nwpwa" are  awkward to me, and possibly
incorrect according to Rajenda's own scheme.

A possible correction in Rajenda's transliteration?
------------------------------------------
Rajenda seems to ignore the trailing
"wabbo" in some of his transliterations.
Maybe, to express the last "wabbo" in such words, Rajenda should spell
them  more correctly as "nw khw wa" or "nw pw wa".
The last "wa" then represents "wabbo" followed by "a-kar". In that case,
the spellings become even more awkward. I wouldn't like to type
"nwpwwa" or "nwkhwwa" if I had a choice!

-----

I like Shyamanta's proposal better because of the considerations
above  unless Rajen da comes up
with a way to distinguish between the  use of "w" as a semi-vowel
in transliteration and the useful
Assamese letter "wabbo" in a more attractive manner.

Jugal Kalita



_______________________________________________
Assam mailing list
[EMAIL PROTECTED]
http://pikespeak.uccs.edu/mailman/listinfo/assam

Reply via email to