I always request both the final model and the experimental data (assuming that they are not yet available directly from the PDB). Obviously, this is done with assurances of confidentiality.
I don't think it's common though, since I was never asked to provide the same by reviewers. What exactly is making you uncomfortable? After all, you have to release everything when your paper is accepted. Cheers, Ed. On Wed, 2012-04-18 at 22:34 +0000, Marc Kvansakul wrote: > Dear CCP4BBlers, > > > I was wondering how common it is that reviewers request to have a copy > of the PDB coordinate file for the review purpose. I have just been > asked to supply this by an editor after several weeks of review, after > one of the reviewers requested a copy. > > > Not having ever been asked to do this before I feel just a tad > uncomfortable about handing this over… > > > Your opinions would be greatly appreciated. > > > Best wishes > > > Marc > > > Dr. Marc Kvansakul > Laboratory Head, NHMRC CDA Fellow > Dept. of Biochemistry| La Trobe University | Bundoora > Rm 218, Phys Sci Bld 4, Kingsbury Drive, Melbourne, 3086, Australia > T: 03 9479 2263 | F: 03 9479 2467 | E: m.kvansa...@latrobe.edu.au | > >
