在 2016年10月28日星期五 UTC+8上午6:43:30,Han Yuwei写道: > 在 2016年10月27日星期四 UTC+8下午6:22:03,[email protected]写道: > > 在 2016年10月27日星期四 UTC+8上午8:09:06,Peter Kurrasch写道: > > > I think these are both good points and my recommendation is that Mozilla > > > deny GDCA's request for inclusion. > > > > > > > > > We should not have to explain something as basic as document versioning > > > and version control. If GDCA can not demonstrate sufficient controls over > > > their documentation, there is no reason for the Internet community to > > > place confidence in any of the other versioning systems that are needed > > > to operate a CA. > > > > > > > > > Question: Are auditors expected to review translations of CP or CPS docs > > > and verify consistency between them? > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > From: Jakob Bohm > > > Sent: Saturday, October 22, 2016 9:07 AM > > > To: [email protected] > > > Subject: Re: Guang Dong Certificate Authority (GDCA) root inclusion > > > request > > > > > > > > > On 21/10/2016 10:38, Han Yuwei wrote: > > > > > > > > I think this is a major mistake and a investgation should be conducted > > > > for CPS is a critical document about CA. This is not just a translation > > > > problem but a version control problem. Sometimes it can be lying. > > > > > > > > > > Let me try to be more specific: > > > > > > When publishing a document called CPS version 4.3 the document with > > > that number must have the same contents in all languages that have a > > > document with that name and version number. > > > > > > When making any change, even just correcting a mistyped URL, the > > > document becomes a new document version which should have a new and > > > larger number than the number of the document before the change. > > > Thus when a published document refers to a broken URL on your own > > > server, it is often cheaper to repair the server than to publish a new > > > document version. Some of the oldest CAs have been proudly > > > publishing their various important files at multiple URLs corresponding > > > to whatever was mentioned in old CP and CPS documents etc., only > > > shutting down those URLs years after the corresponding CA roots were > > > shut down. > > > > > > There can also be a "draft" document which has no number and which > > > contains the changes that will go into the next numbered edition. Such > > > a "draft" would have no official significance, as it has not been > > > officially "published". For a well-planned change, the final "draft" > > > would be translated and checked into the relevant languages (e.g. > > > Chinese with mainland writing system, Chinese with Hong Kong and Macao > > > Special Administrative Regions old writing system, English), before > > > simultaneously publishing the matching documents with the same number > > > on the same day. > > > > > > There are infinitely many version numbers in the universe to choose > > > from. There are also computer programs that can generate new version > > > numbers every time a draft is changed, but computers cannot decide when > > > a version is good enough in all languages to make an official > > > publication, and the computer generated version numbers are often > > > impractical for publication because they count all the small steps that > > > were not published. > > > > > > > > > Enjoy > > > > > > Jakob > > > -- > > > Jakob Bohm, CIO, Partner, WiseMo A/S. https://www.wisemo.com > > > Transformervej 29, 2860 Søborg, Denmark. Direct +45 31 13 16 10 > > > This public discussion message is non-binding and may contain errors. > > > WiseMo - Remote Service Management for PCs, Phones and Embedded > > > _______________________________________________ > > > dev-security-policy mailing list > > > [email protected] > > > https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-security-policy > > > > We’d like to explain a few points. > > > > 1. We have already implemented version control on Chinese version CP/CPS, > > the revision and release of CP/CPS are reviewed and approved by the > > security policy committee (see section 1.5 in CP/CPS). The Chinese version > > CP/CPS is also reviewed by our auditor. > > > > 2. The Chinese version CP/CPS is the formal documents we published in our > > Website. In the initial phase of "Bug 1128392", we have summited the > > Chinese version CP/CPS to Mozilla, and Mozilla release a basic review list > > in file "1128392-CAInformation.pdf" which contains instructions for us to > > summit some chapters of the CP/CPS in English version. We are not able to > > provide an accurate English version CP/CPS, but we will do our best to > > finish this translations and upload for reviewing process. We will upload > > the new English version CP/CPS for reference ASAP. However the English > > version CP/CPS should not be considered as formal documents. In case of any > > discrepancy between two versions, the Chinese version shall prevail. > > > > 3. Our auditor only reviews the Chinese version CP/CPS. It is not their > > responsibility to confirm the translated English versions. > > Since Mozilla's working language is English (Not sure about this), it's your > responsibility to provide an accurate translation of CPS. And I don't think > the problem is poor translation. There is SO MANY DIFFERENCES between Chinese > and English version. As a native Chinese speaker I don't believe the reason > is poor translation but a bit more like you want to cover-up something. > > What I most concern is about the CA certs and alogrithms. The English version > didn't include serveral CA certs and SM2 and can't be explained by > translation. For Wosign's SM2 cert accident, I suspect the missing of SM2 is > intented. > > What's more, there is another possibilty is that the English verison and > Chinese version are maintained seperately.
To make my meaning more accurate, at this time I am NOT supporting the rejection to the inclusion request of GDCA. My proposes are (1.) to make GDCA follow the Mozilla's rules and response to our concerns in time (2.) and to make China Internet more secure. For now I am requesting GDCA to conduct a investgation about the discrepancy of CPS but the representive of GDCA insists on translation problems. If this is it, I am afraid that I would support the rejection. P.S. I do hope that there would be a Chinese CA which can obtain the trust of community but what I experienced now is disappointing me. Maybe I should wait for another decade. _______________________________________________ dev-security-policy mailing list [email protected] https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-security-policy

