On Tue, Apr 25, 2017 at 12:58 AM, Jakob Bohm via dev-security-policy <
[email protected]> wrote:
>
> Look at my two examples of past acquisitions.  As far as I remember, in
> neither case was the purchasing security company previously a trusted
> CA, and they took over practically the whole operation with no initial
> changes besides a name change.
>

Yes. And that worked out badly for security. Put differently, it sounds
like you're suggesting it's more desirable to 'keep everything the same',
when it is fairly consistent that only by changing and integrating is
progress made and security achieved. Both VeriSign and Verizon are proof of
the bad and the good.


> Another variant of this scenario is when a CA restructures its formal
> ownership structure, such as inserting or removing one or more levels
> of companies between the ultimate owners and the CA operations
> activity.  In many cases this would technically be an acquisition by a
> new company that isn't a CA itself (as the acquiring company would
> often be an empty shell).  One example would be the recent creation of
> GTS from part of Google Inc, since GTS was a new company with no past
> CA activity, while the acquired Google division had a past as a SubCA
> and a recently acquired root cert.


I'm afraid I've yet again lost the point you're trying to make.

Perhaps it would help if I stated it differently: Peter's original
suggestion was "The purchaser has not been in compliance with Mozilla
policies for more than 12 months but will ‎do so before the transfer takes
place. The purchaser will then continue to administer/operate/manage the
root in accordance with Mozilla policies."

This would cover the situation of formal restructuring - by providing a
statement of continued commitment.
This would cover the situation of merging/integration - by providing a
statement of continued commitment.
This would cover the situation of independent operation - by providing a
statement of continued commitment.

In response to this, you suggested
"The purchaser intends to retain most of the expertise, personnel,
equipment etc. involved in the operation of the CA, as will
be detailed during such negotiations.

This, or some other wording, would be for a complete purchase of the
business rather than a merge into an existing CA,"

The first sentence has generally resulted in more harm than good. Combined
with the second sentence, it appears you believe this would be the
desirable outcome - moreso than a statement of continued commitment.

I'm asking  you what problem you were trying to solve, and how you sought
to achieve that, because it would seem that your proposal, as an
endorsement for 'independent' operation in such acquisitions, is generally
more harmful than helpful to the Web PKI security.
_______________________________________________
dev-security-policy mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.mozilla.org/listinfo/dev-security-policy

Reply via email to