On Tue, Jun 24, 2008 at 9:40 AM, Felix Meschberger <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > Hi, > > > > Dieter Wimberger schrieb: >> >> Richard: >> >>> The Felix console is the easiest part, I believe, since most of the work >>> is done by the shell service. >> >> Ok. Honestly I don't know, so I could not tell. >> >>> What is the scope of (1), i.e., what functionality is included in it. >> >> At the moment that would be: >> - Telnet >> - SSH2 (based on Jaramiko) >> - Poolable shells (based on commons-pool) >> - Template based output (based on Stringtemplate/Antlr, uses XML files to >> store the templates) >> - Scriptshell (based on Beanshell) >> >> Jaramiko is currently embedded, the bundle is around 360 kB (160 are from >> jaramiko). >> There is also a dependency on commons-collections (buffers and cursorable >> linked list) and SLF4J (logging); > > I for my part would of course love to see this in Apache Felix ! But I think > it is perfectly worth it to keep it where it is (to spread the word and > community around OSGi). > >> >>> >>>> 2 should live at felix (Apache) and may be derived from the old >>>> codebase. If you point me to a codebase I could get started from, I can >>>> invest some time to port and make it working with the newer telnetd >>>> codebase >>>> (i.e. 1). >>> >>> Makes sense and, as I said, it is pretty simple. >> >> I'll investigate a bit later to see if I can get it up and running in a >> felix container instance. I also try to make a short circuit with Craig to >> get this on the road. > > +1 to get this into Felix > >> >>>> I think that your group/committee should decide if you want to get 1 and >>>> 2 or just 2 into the felix project. Either way I'd be doing as much as I >>>> can; it's a long term interest (because the online community I am a part of >>>> since years will switch soon, and we will continue to use the codebase in a >>>> production environment; all OSGi btw.). >>> >>> Ok, great. We will see what others have to say. Thanks. > > As I said, I am all for having (2) in Apache Felix and would warmly welcome > (1) in Felix, too, if the licenses of the used libraries are ok.
+1 regards, Karl > Regards > Felix > -- Karl Pauls [EMAIL PROTECTED]
