I have a comment. Sent from my iPhone
> On Oct 4, 2020, at 12:35 PM, Yanhui ZHAO <[email protected]> wrote: > > > Thanks, Craig > > This is Yanhui Zhao and I am a PMC member. After last ROLL Call I have been > connecting with Gang through weekly meetings regarding the roadmap of > Mnemonic for our next steps, and we are drafting some topics including but > not limited information below. After finalizing the priorities list we will > send it out for the community reviews. You might grow your community if you had this discussion in email on your dev list. > > As we are moving forward we hope a third current PMC member to work with us. > If no current PMC volunteers, we hope to absorb new PMC member if possible to > keep the project moving forward. Engage your dev community in the Apache Way on your dev list. Regards, Dave > > Please take this as my -1 vote with the reasoning above, thanks > > BR > > Yanhui Zhao > > === > Project goal: > To deliver a pre-product durable object model library working with persistent > memory and high performance storage at the end of next year. > > Project objectives > 1) A stable and efficient CI system > 2) A improved documentation and website > 3) Integrated with Bytebuddy > 4) Supporting JDK14 and leveraging the feature of non-volatile mapped byte > buffers (incubator) > 5) Adding Redis as one of backend of durable object > 6) Verified code quality and testing > > Highlights key values of our project is (1) provide unified interface for > storage(memory) backend, (2) remove se-des process to improve the access > speed thus improving read/write performance > > Project Milestones > 1) Dec. 2020, CI documentation and website (v0.14.0) > 2) May. 2021, Bytebuddy and JDK14 (v0.15.0) > 3) Oct. 2020, Redis backend and quality (v0.16.0) > > Project Communication > 1) Weekly regular meeting 30mins - 60 mins > 2) Event based release meeting > 3) Reporting meeting > 4) Maillist, Jira, PR based discussion > 5) Management meeting on demand > > From: Craig Russell <[email protected]> > Sent: Friday, October 2, 2020 3:10 PM > To: [email protected] <[email protected]> > Cc: Apache Board <[email protected]> > Subject: [VOTE] Apache Mnemonic retirement > > Dear members of the Mnemonic Community, > > tl;dr please reply to this message. > > [ ] +1 retire the Mnemonic project > [ ] -1 do not retire the Mnemonic project because... > > I am getting in touch with the Mnemonic community members in regard to the > health of the project. > > There appears to be some work being done but almost all of the activity in > the last several months is from just one person. The most recent board report > states that one PMC member left in August 2020 but I was unable to find any > evidence of this event. > > As projects mature, they will naturally reach a point where activity reduces > to a level such that the project is no longer sustainable. At Apache, > projects reach this stage when there are not at least 3 active PMC members > providing oversight. Projects that reach this stage are usually placed in the > Attic [1] or absorbed by another Apache project willing to manage its > releases. > > On the other hand, if your project has very low activity for good reasons and > has at least three active PMC members willing to perform oversight, it can > remain an Apache project so long as the Board is properly informed and the > project remains open and welcoming to new contributors. > > There was a ROLL CALL last month to which only one PMC member responded. > > At this time, I am requesting a formal VOTE of the Apache Mnemonic community. > If you feel that this project is still viable, and able to reconstitute an > active PMC with at least three members, please respond to this message > accordingly. If you are a member of the PMC but have moved on or are no > longer able to participate, please tell us so that the project's status is > clear. Failure to respond will indicate a lack of interest in oversight. > > Please don't take this message as a criticism of the project or its current > chair. This is an expected event in the timeline of many open source > projects, and sometimes results in a renewed interest from the development > community. > > Best regards, > > Craig > Director, The Apache Software Foundation > [email protected] <mailto:[email protected]> > > [1] https://attic.apache.org/ <https://attic.apache.org/> > >
