On Saturday 06 October 2007 11:05, Diabolic Preacher wrote:
> On 05/10/2007, Graham Lauder <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
> > What I think Sean is talking about is analogous to a note pad
> > and a deskpad that you can scribble on while you are producing
> > a document.  Programmers tend to be linear thinkers, it comes
> > with the territory.  However a script writer for instance  has
> > a myriad of things to think about while writing a screenplay. 
> > Lighting notes, costume stuff, continuity notes, properties,
> > direction detail, characterisation, character histories.  Some
> > of this will make it into the main document.  Some will become
> > a separate bunch of notes, some will become appendices.  None
> > of it lends itself to a linear document production.
>
> It does look like a software like OneNote or BasKet can help you
> but just that you want it as an integral part of the word
> processor and you want specially named collections/notebooks per
> document titled "appendix" and "bibliography" for example.
>
> p.s. No sarcasm intended (though i'm well-known for that) but
> this teaches that desribing how the features of an existing MS
> product exactly fits our needs with such clear details is met
> with less retaliation than a post that's like "Will you guys make
> a OneNote replacement?"

No sarcasm intended but I had to severely edit this reply to keep it 
civil.  You should work on your delivery.

I have discussed this with clients who use One note and it has 
nothing like the functionality of the proposal.  (I personally 
haven't used it because I haven't used windows or MSO in years)

For instance when you are collaborating on a document with multiple 
authors the deskpad goes with the document   One Note, from what I 
understand, is keyed to an individual desktop not the document

> Applause for the smart strategy. :)

No strategy intended

>
> I think on the other hand, the requirement is very specific. I'm
> not saying that only few users would require that, I mean it
> could be that only people with the needs as you describe are more
> in number. 

Actually that's nonsense, most worked like that when pen and paper 
were the norm.  The Computer based model forces us to use a linear 
model of document creation and it is a completely unnatural way for 
the human brain to work for around 80% of the population

>Couldn't the deskpad's feature be added as an
> extension or something?

Developing an extension would be the logical way forward 

Cheers
GL

-- 
"GET LEGAL - GET OPENOFFICE.ORG"
http://why.openoffice.org
ISO 26300 compliant

Graham Lauder,
OpenOffice.org MarCon (Marketing Contact) NZ
http://marketing.openoffice.org/contacts.html

INGOTs Assessor Trainer
Moderator New Zealand
(International Grades in Office Technologies)
www.theingots.org.nz

GET DRESSED GET OOOGEAR
http://ooogear.co.nz

---------------------------------------------------------------------
To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to