cortland.richmond...@ccmailsmtp.ast.com wrote:

< had to snip some stuff >

" the original question was whether courses in complying 
  with regulations should be offered in college."

This is a queston with many parts to it.  
If it's just safety, then no. 
If it's emi/emc, then maybe. 
If it's about just regulations, then no. 

"Isn't this issue more an engineering ethics problem, 
 and a social consequence of our work, than a problem 
 of technical design?"

I would think this should permeate all engineering. 
Hopefully we're all ethical.  Technical design is 
the other side of our work. 

"Getting compliance designed in can be much harder 
 than discovering when it is not." 

Actually, the opposite has been my experience. 
I must as a compliance engineer make myself a 
signatory to: printed circuit board layout, 
system layout, mechanical layout approvals, 
component approvals. 

I must also be a signatory for any ECRs that 
would effect changes to said layouts. Believe me, 
designing in at the beginning is much easier than 
finding out in some lab at 2:00AM.  I've been 
on both sides. 

Alot of the above just cannot be taught in school. 

Regards, Doug
************************************************************
------------------------------------------------------------
   The comments and opinions stated herein are mine alone,
   and do not reflect those of my employer.
------------------------------------------------------------
************************************************************

Reply via email to