Hi,

> Recall that with other PMCs, the PMCs themselves are directly responsible for 
> the development of the code. Not so with the IPMC.

Where is this documented? Where has the board granted this? It’s not in the 
IPMC's policy or in it charter. IMO Until that happens it always going to be a 
cause of conflict in the IPMC.

> Incubation should be a... wait for it... 'safe space' (/me ducks) for 
> podlings to learn the ropes, to fail doing the "normal" things that a PMC 
> must do (including releases), because that is how people learn best. As long 
> as the outworld world is aware that podlings can not, and should not, be 
> expected to be "the same" as other PMCs, we are OK.

I don’t disagree that’s where we would like to be, but I fail to see how people 
outside the ASF would reach that conclusion. The DISCLAMER, for instance, says 
nothing about this.

Thanks,
Justin

Reply via email to