On 01/04/2020 01.12, Thomas Krichel wrote: > Sarven Capadisli writes > >> Does the "the right way" to contribute to scientific communication in >> context of OA require the use of (non- or for-profit) third-party >> services as opposed to self-publishing? > > Yes, it does > >> If so, why? > > because there needs to be persistency to the published output that a > person can not provide. However that persistency layer could be > constructed in such a way that it cost way less than what is paid, > mainly by libraries, to keep the current system going. I'm > currently working on building a persistency layer for RePEc. It's > work funded with a 3000 Euro grant by the French central bank > foundation for economic research. >
By persistency, I assume you mean archival ie. a source deemed to be trustable as it promises to preserve knowledge for long-term. Along the lines of [1]. Isn't archiving an independent and an external function that any actor should have read-write access to ie. to create snapshots and read existing ones? Third-party (non- or for-profit) publishing services neither provide the archival service or expected to, but merely act as a proxy. So then why is it expected that self-publishers are required to fulfil the archiving function? [1] * any Web-wide publicly usable archival services, eg. Internet Archive, archive.is, WebCite, Perma.cc, Webrecorder; * dedicated digital preservation organisations, eg. Portico; * libraries, eg. LOCKSS; * global archives preserving content on behalf of all libraries, eg. CLOCKSS; * subscription based service for all kinds of libraries, federal institutions, state archives, NGOs, eg. Archive-It; * state or federal archives, eg. Swiss Federal Archives, Library and Archives Canada; * institutional-run digital archives, eg. TIB, Zenodo -Sarven https://csarven.ca/#i _______________________________________________ GOAL mailing list [email protected] http://mailman.ecs.soton.ac.uk/mailman/listinfo/goal
