--- Onno Meyer <[email protected]> schrieb am Sa, 30.1.2010:

> Von: Onno Meyer <[email protected]>
> Betreff: Re: [gurps] Around the Globe, as early as possible
> An: "The GURPSnet mailing list" <[email protected]>
> Datum: Samstag, 30. Januar 2010, 12:31
> Caravel or Schooner?
> 
> For tech level 2, the rules allow two masts (VE9) and the
> choice of simple square sails, lugsails, and lateen sails
> (VXi9). On paper, the only difference between lugsails and
> 
> lateen sails are 5° Minimum Upwind Angle more or less. 
> 
> A pair of lateen sails would constitute a caravel, a 
> caravela latina rather than a caravela redonda, like 
> http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:PotugueseCaravel.jpg
> 
> A pair of lugsails, without jibs, might be a schooner 
> roughly like 
> http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Smallschooner.jpg
> 
> Historically, the caravel came earlier than the schooner,
> but is it also easier to build?

As was pointed out before, there is more to either a caravel or a schooner than 
just the sail plan. In terms of what is easier to build, I suspect the twin 
lateen sails are. Also, that's the kind of sail plan that served well for 
monsoon sailing even with huills that were less than ideal for ocean travel. 

Though what you may want to think about is Chinese-style lugsails. Those ships 
are not at all like schooners, but they perform remarkably well. Of course 
they'd require multiple masts (likely more than two, even) to match a hull 
thesize you need, but that configuration was probably around fairly early 
(unless GURPS has again decided to fudge by saying 'The chinese had TL4 ships 
in the first millennium AD"). 

 
> Can there be cramped rowing stations?

I guess thatwould technically be possible, rowing alla scaloccio (multiple men 
to an oar). But I would strongly argue against oars. Any benefit you gain in 
terms of maneuvrability will be lost in range. You simply end up needing more 
hull size and mass to carry the supplies than your additional rowers can move. 
Sweeps, maybe - in which case living space (empty deck for hammocks or mats, 
mess tables and such) would double as rowing station space except where needed. 
Galleys and longships are bad at oceanic voyages. 
 
> I thought of adding oars, which is both in character for 
> a TL2 ship and also used in much later sailing craft, 
> like Captain Kidd's Adventure Galley (at least according
> to the Osprey book on pirate ships). I don't want to 
> spend much weight/volume on those oars, but are cramped
> seats possible for rowers?

The Adventure Galley carried sweeps, which means there were no seats at all and 
almost no space requirement thatwas not used up for other purposes while the 
sweeps were shipped. These are purely auxiliary and mostly used on warships 
because they give you a tactical advantage when becalmed or operating in 
coastal waters. If you're not planning to get into gunfights or cutting-out 
operations, you're much better of carrying a few rowboats. 

I suspect that any extended experiments with ocean sailing will by purely 
Darwinian principles quickly settle ion ships that can be operated by as few 
people as possible. You'll lose too many people to scurvy or tropical diseases 
to man oars or do complicated stuff with big lateen sails (that's really their 
biggest drawback). Personally, when looking at the feastures of European 
sailing vessels of the Early Modern period I'vc always been impressed by the 
fact that from the 17th century onwards, they were routinely sailed by skeleton 
or prize crews of four or five people. 

Volker

__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Sie sind Spam leid? Yahoo! Mail verfügt über einen herausragenden Schutz gegen 
Massenmails. 
http://mail.yahoo.com

_______________________________________________
GurpsNet-L mailing list <[email protected]>
http://mail.sjgames.com/mailman/listinfo/gurpsnet-l

Reply via email to