I'm answering to several mails by David and Volker in one: 

* Regarding the Carvel Hull:

  Looking through Wikipedia and Low-Tech, I don't find any 
  evidence that edge-on-edge planks were necessarily TL3. 
  Volker mentions the cost of the stable TL2 construction,
  and LT agrees with that, so I go for "finely made" along 
  with "expensive materials".

* Regarding Rowing Positions:

  I would imagine that oars (or sweeps) are valuable when
  the ship is close to an unknown coast, especially if it 
  is less agile under sails than more modern ones. Still,
  they would be the secondary mode of propulsion.

  I had a drawing of Kidd's Adventure Galley in mind, but 
  of course she was much larger. Oars moved onto the deck.

* Regarding Crew:

  Vehicles says that my design requires a helmsman, two 
  sailors, a service crewman, and ten rowers per shift. 
  Without oars and disregarding the service, that is a 
  minimum of six for two shifts, or four with just 
  catnaps ...

  I figure to add a master, a mate, a carpenter, and a 
  cook, for a nominal crew of ten, and double that on
  exploration trips for a cooper, a sailmaker, a scribe, 
  soldiers, etc. That should also give enough crew to 
  man the oars from time to time, but not 24/7. 

* Regarding Repairs:

  I've added a carpentry mini-workshop (VXi19). 3,000 
  lbs. of tools and spares should be a starter.

  The rules don't cover spare sails or cordage, something 
  to tell David Pulver for future editions ...

  As a first approximation, you could argue that masts 
  include the standing rigging while sails include the 
  running rigging and spars. That means a second set of
  sails comes with spare rope and some long poles for 
  jury-rigged repairs, and it would be listed as cargo
  rather than part of Ewt. (unlike the craft shop).

* Regarding Motivation and Timeline:

  My assumption was that the basic shape of the continents
  is known, while much exploring and trading remains to be
  done. How to explain that?

  Imagine a situation where a TL2 trader going to England 
  or the atlantic coast of Africa got blown off course by 
  a storm. Months later it returns, battered and with a 
  starving crew, but telling tales of green lands, gold,
  exotic spices, and natives unable to resist conquest.

  If there is a decision to follow up -- and making that 
  decision to start with is REALLY big step -- ships may
  be sent out deliberately. The first would be much like
  ordinary traders, but with extra food and marines in 
  the holds; the first surviving crew gives a faint idea 
  of the distance. 

  Now imagine a generation or two of profitable two-way 
  transatlantic trade. Sure, ships get lost more often 
  than in the Med, but look at the profits! There will
  be ports on both sides of the ocean, and ships built 
  to make one leg of the trip with a sufficient margin 
  of safety and as much payload as possible. Once that 
  pattern is established, other ships might be built as 
  dedicated trade scouts, to push into the white spots 
  of the maps. Enter my Anachronistic Explorer ...

  An alternative scenario could be following the coast 
  of Africa to get a sea route to India and China. The 
  mission wouldn't start with an ocean crossing, but 
  again the age of exploration would start early.

* Regarding the Round-The-Globe Specification:

  The scenario could imply a gradual approach, building
  ports along foreign coastlines. So why ask for global
  range? 

  I recall from the "experimental archeology" adventures
  that TL1 rafts or reed boats might be able to cross the 
  Atlantic ONCE -- afterwards they're fit for scrap. So 
  those craft were good for a couple of weeks, a couple 
  of thousand miles, but I want to do better at TL2.

  One reason is that explorers won't move in a straight 
  line. So if a ship has a theoretical range/endurance 
  to circle the globe, it will have the endurance to 
  start out from a port, cross an ocean or follow the 
  coastline some more, look for the next building site,
  and return with the logs and maps. 

  Alternatively, the round-the-globe ship could be built
  by newcomers on the global scene, who know the basics 
  from their spies in foreign capitals, but who want 
  their own contacts with the growers of silk and tea.

  Either way, I could imagine a progression from traders
  with a single square sail to explorers with a single 
  lateen or lugsail to explorers with two sails.

* Regarding Chinese Sails:

  VXi makes them TL3, while I aim for TL2.
_______________________________________________
GurpsNet-L mailing list <[email protected]>
http://mail.sjgames.com/mailman/listinfo/gurpsnet-l

Reply via email to