--- Onno Meyer <[email protected]> schrieb am Mo, 25.1.2010:

> Volker replied to me:
> > Post TL 1, I wouldn't see this as a 'hard' technology
> challenge as much as
> > a knowledge one. The equipment and skills to build
> oceangoing ships ois
> > around from the great Bronze Age civilisations
> onwards. 
> 
> Certain 'soft' factors are still TL-dependent, like
> Navigation. I
> see no real difference between finding better ways to cast
> bronze
> and finding better ways to navigate -- both uplift the area
> TL. 

True, but one is easier to achieve than the other. Look at the way so many 
effectively stone-age civilisations developed huge advances ion mathematics and 
astronomy. It's the kind of thing you can do almost completely independent of 
material resources.

Still, soft tech is your biggest obstacle. Equipping TL2 sailors with the gear 
to sail to the Americas is easy compared to equipping them with the mindset and 
skills to do so.
 
> > IN terms of
> > seaworthiness, a Polynesian outrigger canow would
> already answer your purpose,
> > though of course it wouldn't carry the crew or payload
> you'd need.
> 
> * VXi8 calls it TL3 ... guess they were advanced in one
> area. 

Wow. Talk about a fudge.
 
> * Would it really be able to brave the Capes?

Good Hope certainly, though only in season. The Horn is more dangerous, but 
it's amazing what kind of weather an open vessel can survive. Of course a 
Pollynesian crew would not be equipped to deal with the cold and the lack of 
revictualling and refitting opportunities.

 
> * Preserving food and water will be a challenge. 

It's kind of achicken-and-egg-thing. As long as your society doesn't need 
technologies to preserve food for that long, it won't develop them, and as long 
as it doesn't have them, it won't reckon a voyage of that length possible. 
Still, salting and lactic acid fermentation, drying, pickling and preserving in 
oil were understood at TL2. A history of exploration will create a body of 
experience about how to optimise it for sea voyages. 
 
> * TL1 ships don't tack all that well. Even with generally
> good and 
>   predictable winds, that will increase the duration
> of the voyage.

Not by very much. Even at TL5, sailing ships as a rule followed known trade 
winds and weather patterns whenever they could. Of course, without the TL4 
knowledge of the Atlantic trade wind systems, the preferred approach was to 
wait for favourable winds which *would* lengthen the voyage greatly. Again, 
earlier systematic exploration could create that knowledge.
 

> Trade winds restrict the direction and timing of the
> voyage. The 
> idea was to take one ship all the way, no overland trips
> e.g. in
> Panama. Once you're in the south Atlantic, you can start to
> go 
> east all the way around, but getting there could be tricky,
> and 
> it isn't exactly a nice part of the world, either.

You can work with seasonalsailing. It was customary before Western and Chinese 
sailors developed the idea of basically living at sea to plan lengthy stays in 
ports while waiting for the seasons to change. Sailing around the world doesn't 
need to mean sailing around the earth in one go.
 

> Below you mention a step-by-step approach. What I had in 
> mind was the culmination of several improving designs.

That should work, though I'd love to hear how the tech tree progresses. 
 
> > Nobody had experience
> > with maintaining a vessel under way because people
> used to go ashore for
> > any repair. 
> 
> What can you do underway anyway, when it comes to hull 
> repair?

Quite a lot. I think it was mostly a matterof psychology. European sailors 
mastered these skills in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, presumably 
because they felt safer aboard than ashore in much of the world. 

Basically, a European-style sailing ship under way can replace spars, yards and 
even masts from spares carried on board (though usually not of the same size). 
Minor leaks could be plugged completely while larger ones could be at least 
mitigated by deploying leaksails and shoring up the hull from the inside. Given 
enough wood to work with, you could jury-rig rudders while at sea and replace 
large parts of the planking while beached. Basically, as long as your keel and 
ribs are reasonably intact, you can rebuild your ship  in any sheltered bay. It 
does require you to carry extra amounts of nails, tar, oakum, rope and 
sailcloth, though. AFAIK, that kind of tzhing was a European specialy. Their 
ships are supremely well adapted to it, and they invented the skills much like 
Central Asian nomads built a culture around moving on horseback. It is not a 
matter of course. No TL2 sailor would think it possible, though technologically 
it would have been, just like no
 TL4 dragoon or cuirassier would have considered riding from the Volga to the 
Amur with just the contents of his saddlebags.
 
> > Nobody understood high seas navigation because you
> used leadlines
> > and landmarks. 
> 
> I thought that would be a real problem.

It may well be. The basic principles aren't that hard to develop, but you 
actuially have to do it, which pretty much means you'll have to want to do 
high-seas sailing. And of course there are alternatives. You can navigate by 
currents and clouds, if you really know what you're doing. Astronomical 
navigation is easier to learn, though. The other approach is prone to ending 
you in a high-level equilibrium trap.
 
> > Nobody had any understanding of the weather or
> prevailing
> > winds and currents, so as far as they knew, you could
> get stuck in eternal
> > calm or ripped to pieces by monster storms. 
> 
> The starting point was a rough idea of the shape of the 
> continents. To get that knowledge without alien or divine
> intervention, somebody must have survived each individual
> portion of the trip before. The idea was to write a ship
> which can do all parts in sequence.

Why?

Though, of course, if you have ships that can reliably do the separate parts of 
the voyage, they should already be capable of doing the whole. 
 
> > You can't build a shiop to
> >  be prepared for all of this, so chances are the
> resuzlting design wpould
> > be a poor compromise and probably doomed to kill its
> crew by starvation or
> > thirst somewhere in a nice, blue stretch of sea under
> a friendly trade wind
> > taking them in the wrong direction. 
> 
> So the first ship might carry extra food instead of trade
> goods.

A ship built for exploration is unlikely to carry many trade goods at all. The 
early caravels were built to carry a crew and its supplies, almost nothing 
more. Building a merchant ship that can usefully sail around the world with a 
cargo is a challenge of an entirely different order. 
  

> Management of supplies includes both preservation and
> rationing.
> For setting rations, take the normal duration of the leg
> and a 
> Murphy factor, higher on early voyages and lower later on.

You'd have to have an idea of what the normal length is. Of course you can 
always start cutting rations later in the voyage. 
 
> Repair underway will be tricky. A carpentry workshop can
> only 
> do so much. Would a convoy be useful, or will it just get 
> scattered anyway?

A convoy would be very useful, if only to cannibalise and abandon ships as they 
suffer damage or the crew numbers dwindle. Generally, sailing together, 
especially if you can fix rendezvous points in advance, works well. Repairs are 
also made easier if you can use one ship as a platform to service another and 
muster the extra boats and crew if you need them for big operations. 
 

 
> Those steps will take years of sailing time alone, like the
> 
> Portugese going around Africa inch by inch. 

Half a century at least, I suspect. Henc my comparison to the Apollo Project.
  


> Low-Tech (3E) doesn't mention cooperage, and CI has no TL
> for 
> it. High-Tech (4E) doesn't go into details on lower TLs. 

I don't think it is tech-level dependent. It's just one of many fairly simple 
solutions for a problem that just happened to be very well suited to an 
application nobody thought of at the time. You can certainly justify calling it 
TL2, since it was widely used by the Celts and Romans. Casks are amazing 
things, far superior to pottery containers on long voyages, re-useable, 
collapsible, and easily improvised. Without them, you'll have to find 
alternative solutions to a host of problems.
   
 
Volker

__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Sie sind Spam leid? Yahoo! Mail verfügt über einen herausragenden Schutz gegen 
Massenmails. 
http://mail.yahoo.com

_______________________________________________
GurpsNet-L mailing list <[email protected]>
http://mail.sjgames.com/mailman/listinfo/gurpsnet-l

Reply via email to