On Sun, Jan 31, 2010 at 6:27 AM, Onno Meyer <[email protected]> wrote:
> I'm answering to several mails by David and Volker in one: > > * Regarding the Carvel Hull: > > Looking through Wikipedia and Low-Tech, I don't find any > evidence that edge-on-edge planks were necessarily TL3. > They're not: the Egyptians were doing it at the time of pyramids at Giza, and probably well before. But theirs were stressed skin boats, held together with rope tension > Volker mentions the cost of the stable TL2 construction, > and LT agrees with that, so I go for "finely made" along > with "expensive materials". > This is one of those things that's hard to work through: without advanced sail plans, there's little reason to build a carvel boat; other construction methods are lighter, cheaper, more economical iwth internal volume, and more. But without carvel construction, it's hard to make advanced sail plans. the history of technology is riddled with countless examples of this. One of the big drivers of technological progress has been the greater dispersal of knowledge, and better application of knowledge from one field to others, and from one place to others. * Regarding Rowing Positions: > > I would imagine that oars (or sweeps) are valuable when > the ship is close to an unknown coast, especially if it > is less agile under sails than more modern ones. Still, > they would be the secondary mode of propulsion. > yes. > > I had a drawing of Kidd's Adventure Galley in mind, but > of course she was much larger. Oars moved onto the deck. > > * Regarding Crew: > > Vehicles says that my design requires a helmsman, two > sailors, a service crewman, and ten rowers per shift. > Without oars and disregarding the service, that is a > minimum of six for two shifts, or four with just > catnaps ... > > I figure to add a master, a mate, a carpenter, and a > cook, for a nominal crew of ten, and double that on > exploration trips for a cooper, a sailmaker, a scribe, > soldiers, etc. That should also give enough crew to > man the oars from time to time, but not 24/7. > > That seems really, really low. -- David Scheidt [email protected] _______________________________________________ GurpsNet-L mailing list <[email protected]> http://mail.sjgames.com/mailman/listinfo/gurpsnet-l
