Le 30 janv. 2014 à 13:55, Alexandru Petrescu <[email protected]> a écrit :
> Pierre, > > Thanks for the reply. > > Le 30/01/2014 13:46, Pierre Pfister a écrit : >> >> Le 30 janv. 2014 à 13:38, Alexandru Petrescu >> <[email protected]> a écrit : >> >>> Le 30/01/2014 13:28, Ole Troan a écrit : >>>>>>> Could it be separate (existing) protocol? >>>>>> >>>>>> if one had existed, sure. requirements from homenet-arch (I >>>>>> might have missed some): - must support multi-homing - each >>>>>> link should be assigned a stable prefix - efficient >>>>>> allocation of prefixes - should support both IPv4 and IPv6 >>>>> >>>>> I meant this: >>>>> >>>>> loosely coupled ---- separate (existing DHCPv6-PD) protocol >>>>> triggering route updates to the routing protocol. >>>> >>>> yes, DHCP PD comes up as a proposed solution quite frequently. I >>>> just don't see how you can make DHCP PD fulfill the >>>> requirements. >>> >>> Well it does support multi-homing (Server allocates things to as >>> many interfaces as needed), each link can be assigned a stable >>> prefix (provided it triggers updates to the Routing protocol), the >>> allocation is efficient (Server maintains dynamic databases, >>> leases) and it supports both IPv4 ('IPv4 subnet allocation' >>> RFC6656, DHCP transition et alia), and IPv6. >>> >>> I miss something? >> >> Well, in some cases DHCP seems to work, but not when you start >> imagining multi-homed networks with multiple routers. Or maybe you >> can tell me how to solve this situation with DHCP: >> >> You have ISP1 connected with Router 1. ISP2 connected with Router 2. >> Router 1, Router 2, and a third Router (Router 3), are connected on >> the same link. ISP1 is delegated the prefix A/56 to Router 1. ISP2 >> is delegating the prefix B/56 to Router 2. >> >> A host is connected behind Router 3. > > Bear with me for a moment... is this topology what you meant? > > > ISP1 ISP2 > | | > +-------+ +-------+ > |Router1|A/56 |Router2|B/56 > +-------+ +-------+ > | | > --+-------+----------+-- > | > | > +-------+ > |Router3| > +-------+ > | > +----+ > |Host|(how can it get an address from A, and from B) > +----+ > > >> How can it get addresses from both prefixes ? > > Before I try to figure it out - is the above topology what is meant? > Something I misplaced? It is correct. Pierre > > Alex > >> >> Cheers, >> >> Pierre >> >> >>> >>> Alex >>> >>>> >>>> cheers, Ole >>>> >>> >>> >>> _______________________________________________ homenet mailing >>> list [email protected] >>> https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/homenet >> >> >> > > _______________________________________________ homenet mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/homenet
