Re: draft-ietf-nat-protocol-complications-02.txt

[Jon Crowcroft]

In message <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>, Masataka Ohta ty
ped:
 
 >>     Is it fair if providers using iMODE or WAP are advertised
 >>     to be ISPs?
 >>
 >>     Is it fair if providers using NAT are advertised to be ISPs?
 >>
 >>My answer to both questions is
 >>
 >>     No, while they may be Internet Service Access Providers and
 >>     NAT users may be IP Service Providers, they don't provide
 >>     Internet service and are no ISPs.

i agree:
in the UK, i would say that someone claiming internet access via WAP
would be in breach of the trades description act.

 >>Any oppositions?
 
not from here (for wap - i dont know enough about iMODE to comment)
 >>                                             Masataka Ohta
 >>

 cheers

   jon