IMHO the big difference between the 4.x to 5.x migration and the one
from 5.x to 6.x is who do the changes benefit. I think Rasmus made a
very true and correct statement, PHP 6, who's main offering (at least
right now) is unicode support is mostly for the 3-4% of the user base
inside large companies like Yahoo that need to deploy multi-language
applications and have full control over their environment. For the
average joe, PHP 6 is not needed because as a rule they develop for 1
locale, which is something PHP can already do quite well, if the #s
of PHP based sites are to be taken into account. This means that
there is absolutely nothing of value that the average use has to gain
by moving from 5.x aside from drop in speed, which I am sure will be
a winner for hosting companies and guaranteed BC breaks. From that
perspective, I think PHP 6 adoption will be very slow, even compared
to the luckster 5.x adoption rates, which only in the last year have
began to pickup steam.
Given that it is the case I think PHP 5 will be supported for a very
long time and eventually may even take a life of its own simply due
to the large user base it will have, that has nothing to gain by
moving to PHP 6. Keeping in mind that aside from unicode any other
features/additions of PHP 6 could be easily ported to PHP 5 by one
who is interested in them.
On 20-Jun-07, at 7:32 AM, Pierre wrote:
On 6/20/07, Jani Taskinen <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
What I think Ilia said (between the lines) is that basically we're
forking PHP.
Perhaps we really need to accept the fact that this has already
happened..
It started with the CPR for PHP_4_4 branch and same is now
continuing with
the PHP_5_2 branch. If the support for PHP 4 was _officially_
dropped by release
of PHP 5, the adoption of PHP 5 would have been quicker than it
has been so far.
You are right, that's one of the only way to "force" the move, the
only one I can imagine at least.
A realistic way to do it is to say that 5.x will not be supported 2
years (or so) after the first stable release of php6. That's still
~5-10 years with a maintained php5.x (ok, 5.0.x was born dead ;).
(No need to say that php4 support should have been stopped already)
--Pierre
Ilia Alshanetsky
--
PHP Internals - PHP Runtime Development Mailing List
To unsubscribe, visit: http://www.php.net/unsub.php
