Your points are probably valid and there might be a chance to have them addressed if you for each point you stated suggest a concrete change. As it is written now you mainly stated your emotional response with little description of the underlying cause or how to make it better.
Just a thought. BR, John On Wed, Nov 12, 2008 at 12:49 PM, 米兰(milan) <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Hi guys, > > everyone saying how Netbeans's great, but I have completely different > opinion. > > I decided to try Netbeans(6.2) after long period with eclipse. But I > switched back. > I use it mainly for java(web) development > > 1. it does not have native look and feel on my Linux box(and I didn't > like netbeans look and feel either) > > 2. I had several (principal) problems with building concept using a > ant. In addition netbeans forced me to use newer versions of ant, > something I could do, since we use older version to build projects and > I don't want to have 10 versions of ant on my comp. > > 3. I didn't like subversion integration. I love subclipse, maybe > reason is that I use it as main subversion tool on Linux(there are > some options here, but I didn't like them so much). Especially I > lacked subversion repository browser tool. > > 4. UML plugin doesn't work to my contempt. I lost a lot of > data,diagrams etc, even I saved them. > > 5. Slow switch between project groups (lightning fast working groups > in eclipse) > > 6. I lacked(maybe it exists but I didn't find it) functionality, where > you can navigate to file in project explorer from source editor. When > you have 20 files open from different packages and from different > projects, it is easily to get lost. > > 7. I think creation wizards(class,interfaces) are much better in > eclipse > > 8. I didn't like netbeans force you to have certain project structure. > > 9. maven2 integration was not satisfactory in nb 6.2(if either) > > 10. I like much more debugging in eclipse, I just feel more > comfortable over there. Better thread overview etc. > > 11. I like more eclipse way of handling plugins.Especially not > standard plugins were harder to maintain in netbeans than in eclipse > > 12. I like junit plugin more in eclipse, just my impression > > I gave it a shot, but I was not very satisfied(I used it over 5 > months). Maybe I am too used to eclipse and I have problems with new > working patterns. > > maybe I should try 6.5 but not here in work environment, I just feel I > am more productive with eclipse. > > I have problems with eclipse, oh yes I do a lot of them, e specially > with some plugins, but I still feel more comfortable with eclipse then > with nb. > > milan > > > On Nov 10, 3:34 pm, Casper Bang <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > True, the project group is somewhat of an afterthought (started as a > > 6.0 plugin) and it has been showing. But in 6.5rc it seems much more > > stable and reliable than previously, although still horrendously slow > > and without any visual indications as to what's going on (yes I have > > filed a RFE). > > > > /Casper > > > > On Nov 10, 3:24 pm, mbien <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > > > On Nov 10, 9:31 am, "Adam G." <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > > > > > I also have to admit that the plugin system of NetBeans is much > better > > > > that the Eclipse thing. Sometimes you mess up you configuration and > > > > then you can not update anymore because of conflicts. And till now it > > > > was to complicated to resolve them somehow so I always did a new > > > > installation :) But still I use Eclipse and love it! > > > > > > One thing I still don't understand as a Eclipse user with NetBeans is > > > > the workspace. In Eclipse I have several projects in one workspace, > > > > and if I want to tidy things up I create working sets and thats it. > > > > And now in NetBeans I have a workspace and a *default project*. Why > do > > > > I have to have a default project and what is the meaning behind that? > > > > > NetBeans has project groups which are very similar to workspaces, just > > > create/switch/edit a project group by clicking with RMB on the project > > > view. The nice thing about them is that you can reuse one project in > > > multiple groups which is IMO quite usefull in some situations. > > > > > NetBeans 6.5 works also without a main project, the behavior in this > > > mode should be very similar to eclipse. > > > > > > Cheers! > > > --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "The Java Posse" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/javaposse?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
